Mafia Redd's Revenge - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[Damniel]

I think part of Betsy's read on me is just a general distrust in me as a player (which I obvs can't do anything about). the read also just feels like an inaccurate portrayal of me as she's expecting me to have strong wolf reads D1 and that trying to find town isn't also solving which I strongly disagree with

 

[BetsySundrop]

I’d definitely rather one of Dan/ribbit/shell get voted off

Same, lol.

I dont know who else is new but I feel like I wouldn’t wanna say anything if I was mafia, so perhaps Bongo or Dinosaur could be a partner?

Always possible, you never know. I think it's easier once the first wolf is uncovered. You can look back at their interactions.

 

[Damniel]

I’d definitely rather one of Dan/ribbit/shell get voted off

how did you reach to this conclusion?

 

[BetsySundrop]

I think part of Betsy's read on me is just a general distrust in me as a player (which I obvs can't do anything about). the read also just feels like an inaccurate portrayal of me as she's expecting me to have strong wolf reads D1 and that trying to find town isn't also solving which I strongly disagree with

It's really not. It's oddball stuff you're posting. Like last game, dolby seemed fishy to me (he was!), and his defense was that i just didn't trust him/wanted to see him wolfy. So similar.

I also did not say trying to find town wasn't solving. I said, it wasn't good to rely on poe alone because that always ends up with dead town d1.

So find town, make poe, but then the next step - question the people in your poe and try to figure them out.

I've questioned people, tried to figure out whether they're town/wolf, tried to encourage activity with direct questions - meh.

I know I'm flipping town, and the graveyard is always fun, but I will definitely defend, because we need the numbers this game.

 

[shellbell]

ok but guys, guys, what if it’s dan and ness because they are so split that if one flips wolf the other will never be sussed again

 

[Damniel]

I dont know who else is new but I feel like I wouldn’t wanna say anything if I was mafia, so perhaps Bongo or Dinosaur could be a partner?

I think that, regardless of alignment, a player would at least post or something. im more inclined to believe Bongo is just MIA so I think the slot is null for now and hope they step in/are replaced

 

[N e s s]

ok but guys, guys, what if it’s dan and ness because they are so split that if one flips wolf the other will never be sussed again

god i wish honestly

 

[BetsySundrop]

ok but guys, guys, what if it’s dan and ness because they are so split that if one flips wolf the other will never be sussed again

I would figuratively cry.

I dunno. I think ness just seems town.

 

[Damniel]

It's really not. It's oddball stuff you're posting. Like last game, dolby seemed fishy to me (he was!), and his defense was that i just didn't trust him/wanted to see him wolfy. So similar.

I also did not say trying to find town wasn't solving. I said, it wasn't good to rely on poe alone because that always ends up with dead town d1.

So find town, make poe, but then the next step - question the people in your poe and try to figure them out.

I've questioned people, tried to figure out whether they're town/wolf, tried to encourage activity with direct questions - meh.

I know I'm flipping town, and the graveyard is always fun, but I will definitely defend, because we need the numbers this game.

In Dolbys defense it is frustrating when people just expect you to play a certain way so it's annoying when this happens

You're a better solver than this.

defend yourself then!!
don’t let me and ness walk all over you

I think I've been talking about and engaging with everyone. I just wanna take it easy and not be so intense about things and these feel like unfair summations

 

[Doo]

how did you reach to this conclusion?

ribbit seemed a bit too passionate about accusing someone else early on.
Shell’s thing about wanting to vote people off was a bit suspicious, and after I asked about it, they started getting suspicious of me. I really don’t know about them.
As for you Dan, I dont know what Poe means but you seem to be against what Ness is saying and I think I trust Ness. I’m wary though, since you both seem really good at this.

I’m not certain about anything but I can’t suspect Dinosaur yet, and Betsy seems too natural to be mafia.
The only suspicions I’ve had have been of Dan, shell and ribbit, that’s all really lol.

 

[Damniel]

I dont know what Poe means

process of elimination. Figuring out who town is so anyone not town is possible mafia by process of elimination

I'm going to note that Doo mind melds with Ness a lot but the point that he and I have opposing reads is an original thought I think

 

[BetsySundrop]

In Dolbys defense it is frustrating when people just expect you to play a certain way so it's annoying when this happens

I didn't expect dolby to play a certain way. I just thought he was fishy. You were on my fishy list, so I'm pointing out things that don't seem solvy.

A lot can happen in a day. Maybe dino will post, etc. But to pick who i would vote right now, it's you or ribbit.

 

[ribbitribbon]

ribbit seemed a bit too passionate about accusing someone else early on.
Shell’s thing about wanting to vote people off was a bit suspicious, and after I asked about it, they started getting suspicious of me. I really don’t know about them.
As for you Dan, I dont know what Poe means but you seem to be against what Ness is saying and I think I trust Ness. I’m wary though, since you both seem really good at this.

I’m not certain about anything but I can’t suspect Dinosaur yet, and Betsy seems too natural to be mafia.
The only suspicions I’ve had have been of Dan, shell and ribbit, that’s all really lol.

who did i accuse passionately early on?

 

[shellbell]

Shell’s thing about wanting to vote people off was a bit suspicious, and after I asked about it, they started getting suspicious of me. I really don’t know about them.

it’s fine if you think wanting to vote is suspicious, but i wanna clarify that i wasn’t suspicious of you after you asked about it. i had those thoughts before, and i only said my issues with your message after ness asked what my susses were. i actually wasn’t going to mention them at this stage.

 

[Doo]

who did i accuse passionately early on?

Nobody. I remembered it wrong sorry
@Damniel

This is what I meant:

no what is YOUR opinion on voting me first

But i dont know if it means anything now

 

[ribbitribbon]

it’s fine if you think wanting to vote is suspicious, but i wanna clarify that i wasn’t suspicious of you after you asked about it. i had those thoughts before, and i only said my issues with your message after ness asked what my susses were. i actually wasn’t going to mention them at this stage.

ngl i agree with this a lot
i keep a lot of my strong wolf reads + reasonings to myself until later because im afraid of causing a war
it’s why i let dolby walk all over me even though i thought he was maf lmao

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2024

wait did i miss something
@Damniel why the betsy vote?

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2024

I think part of Betsy's read on me is just a general distrust in me as a player (which I obvs can't do anything about). the read also just feels like an inaccurate portrayal of me as she's expecting me to have strong wolf reads D1 and that trying to find town isn't also solving which I strongly disagree with

if i’m reading correctly this is just difference of opinion so im not sure why you are

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2024

Betsy tonally just feels forced in some of the posts so voting there for neo

i guess there is this

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2024

oh wait that is the explanation
i misread

 

[Doo]

it’s more like
there are 6 other villagers and 2 maf members so i don’t mind tring like 6 people, if nothing stands out for the sake of discussion then it’s a tr

i really hope you feel better food poisoning is the literal worse especially the weird stuff that happens to your mouth… hang in there

i agree w this, i don’t think we are gonna have strong srs until people talk longer


sheeping my reads and then fossing me!!??

nah im just kidding but i would agree that the dan/shell slots are my biggest leads rn just based on vibes alone. i would like to hear more from the inactives before looking into to either closely though

Post automatically merged: Jun 13, 2024

omg the first part of that post i typed out last night and meant to delete

Looking back because I didn’t understand what was going on at the time, this sounds like a town thing to say?

 

[N e s s]

It would be pretty fun if the team is dinosaur and bongo

 

[Dinosaur]

Back with some brief thoughts on the main topics of conversation:

Ribbit: I don't get the (potential) ribbot wagon? I know some are suspicious of them but the way they are acting is similar to the last game (at least in my opinion). I could be horribly wrong though, I thought they were mafia most of last game when they were town lol.

Ness: As i said earlier he seems to be acting similarly to last game so I'm not sure about him yet.

Dan: I have absolutely no baseline for what he acts like in game so I have nothing there

Betsy: Also seems similar to last game so far

 

[BetsySundrop]

It would be pretty fun if the team is dinosaur and bongo

Actually yes. Yes it would.