Iirc one of the hosts said that there can be multiple of any role. So even if there was, that just means two possible cowards one or both of which we'd lynch in typical TBT fashion.
-
The first day of our new Mushroom Season event has passed, but things are just getting started. Read the update about changes made to the schedule, starting with day two. Be careful foraging and good luck! -
Come and see the official gallery showcasing all of your creative entries from The Bell Tree Fair 2024. In addition, the winners for the final raffles have been drawn! Click here for the event's final closing announcement.
Mafia Reindeer Mafia! - WE'RE DONE GUYS - YETI WIN
- Thread starter Kit
- Start date
Iirc one of the hosts said that there can be multiple of any role. So even if there was, that just means two possible cowards one or both of which we'd lynch in typical TBT fashion.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Blu Rose could be scum too. Kinda contridicts my pet theory but I've been wrong with Day 1 pet theories before so.
Well if I have to tell you on mobile so be it...
I'd say say Daniel is town. I can't exactly make this a solid read as I'm on mobile, but I'm liking his recent posts. Last game when Daniel was arsonist he led a poorly made wagon against me I'll say that. So if he starts acting a bit like that game then he should be at FoS.
I'd say say Daniel is town. I can't exactly make this a solid read as I'm on mobile, but I'm liking his recent posts. Last game when Daniel was arsonist he led a poorly made wagon against me I'll say that. So if he starts acting a bit like that game then he should be at FoS.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Stop giving us updates and finish 'em already plox.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Daniel leading poorly made wagons isn't an alignment indication. =P
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm going to go grab food. I hope Daniel's reads are up by the time I get back.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Daniel leading poorly made wagons isn't an alignment indication. =P
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm going to go grab food. I hope Daniel's reads are up by the time I get back.
Either way we don't have that much longer to determine a new candidate. We could stick to Haydenn and hope that they do flip as mafia. We could switch to Blu, Daniel, Nessy or Luca. Either way roles arent guaranteed to be used or there may be multiple.
What do the rest of you think/feel
What do the rest of you think/feel
Lol ik but I can't describe it right now, I'll tell you if he reminds me of it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This post sticks out to me just a bit, just saying.
Well I'm going to go do homework. I'll vote in due time.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
That post stuck out to me too.
- - - Post Merge - - -
So stop posting and read. =P
I'm unvoting Haydenn. I can see how his actions make sense from a coward's standpoint. Haydenn's a coward. That means that he is immune to all actions on two occasions that he chooses. Naturally, with this role, he would try to prevent the mafia from killing any one, and indicate that he had a killing role. Both the vigilante and the serial killer would be threats from the mafia's perspective, so they would kill him. But not anticipating them using their ninja hitman kill on him, or them using it with a 50% chance of going through, making them likely wasting a hit. This is a very good plan in theory, but in practice, it isn't. He made himself a lynch candidate, which I had a part in admittedly, so now he's forced to claim as coward and the mafia won't waste kills or blocks on him.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Tbh it's a good plan in practice too. I've lured mafia into trying to kill me before when I have roles that counter the killing blow.
It's all about execution though. You never straight up say something like "I know who I'll kill. Hint, hint, but never say.
- - - Post Merge - - -
fite me irl blu
It's all about execution though. You never straight up say something like "I know who I'll kill. Hint, hint, but never say.
- - - Post Merge - - -
fite me irl blu
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2014
- Posts
- 13,849
- Bells
- 1,008
- Sautéed Mushrooms
- 0
- Spores
- 0
- Switch
- 0804-8939-7771
- Island
- Sandoval
Okay guys, here are my reads, from least to most wolfy. Using colors like usual, Green is townie, Yellow is suspicious, Red is mafia.
Dinger-Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that.
Sarnone-Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that
Jellofish- Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that.
Reyy-Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that. However, i did find this quote to be weird
These 4 people have just been really inactive, which is okay for newbies on Day 1.But later as the games goes on, being inactive starts to get very suspicious, so I want to hear more from you all.
Enderwiggin- Pretty quiet as of now. I know you said you said i was wolf at the very beginning, voted for me, and then said i?m wolf again. But you haven?t made a case on me, so i just dismissed it as you trying to see if i freak out or something like that. Not enough posts to read from though. But i?m acknowledging your suspicions, but until i see a case on me i can?t really do much about it.
Dolby- He hasn?t posted a whole lot, but was the first to bring up the case of Haydenn. While i don?t think Haydenn?s case had much merit, his reaction and behavior so far is pretty weird. Overall just helping town.
Lucanosa- You?re pretty weird to read, you have posted every once in awhile, but your posts don?t really help town. You?re relatively new to mafia, so maybe you don?t know how to wolf hunt yet, but I don?t think anything you?ve said is too wolfy. I would however, like to hear your thoughts and opinions whenever you get to reading the game properly.
Blu Rose- I haven?t played with you much outside of tiny quick games, so i don?t really know your playstyle. You overall seem to not really help town, but haven?t said anything wolfy. You seem like a good player so i?m thinking you're just reading and waiting to make a good case, so nothing wolfy to me so far.
Ayaya- New player, but surprisingly brought up suspicions on someone Jacob, another newbie even. You stray from the other inactives newbies in the fact that you started a case on someone. But it?s not the strongest case i?ve seen, you seem pretty off to me in not just bandwagoning. Either you?re just bold,or you had a team telling you what to do? Not my priority suspicion but I want to make note of it.
Ashot- He is pretty hard to read in games i play with him, he always sht posts no matter what alignment. I find it weird how he wants to lynch Starry just because ?I don?t like her? but it?s only day one and i don?t think he would be saying wolfy stuff like that as mafia, especially from an experienced member. I think you?re town as of now.
Tom- He tends to immediately go from Sht posting to serious posting when he?s mafia. I haven?t seen any wolfy posts here, but he has the behavior of wolf. You even saying "Let me finish sht posting" stuck me as odd too, You are usually very hard to read, which makes me always wonder whether or not you're mafia.
Trojan- The wildcard like always. You switch from silly to serious, typical playstyle of town trojan. I do find your pms to people a bit odd though. Maybe you?re just trying to get reactions and thoughts from the otherwise quiet newbies, but i?ve never seen you do this before it raises an eyebrow.
Starrywolf- Inactive like always, i know you have boarding school or something like that so i don?t find it suspicious anymore. However, the one post you did do was you pushing your town claim again. You did it in smash mafia when you were mafia, so i don?t think you would make that mistake again as mafia. I think your town so far, but since you are kinda acting like you did as mafia in smash, won?t completely dismiss it.
Jacob- You seem to excuse yourself a lot, in almost all your post you say stuff like ?Oh sorry i was busy doing something/I will post later/making excuses? when it?s not really needed. Being a new player, it could just be your fear of people being suspicious of you for being inactive, but you have yet to say any thoughts you have so far. I?m reading more noob playing than anything else though.
N e s s- Trying to scum hunt this whole game, maybe too hard, but that?s what he usually does so it doesn?t surprise me. You used traps that don?t really make sense in the DA:I mafia game, and you were mafia. Still don?t get why you set a trap for tom and tom alone. But you were pressing really hard on some people so i don?t think wolves would be the ones to start a bandwagon like that because when they flip they get the blame. Leaning more towards town but i could see you as mafia.
Haydenn- While i believe Dolby?s case on you is rather weak, i find your reaction to it and behavior afterwards to be very interesting. Here are some quotes and my reaction to it:
This was from very early in the day, when the Starry wagon was starting. I find it weird that you would suggest forcing someone to claim so early in day one, when she wasn?t on the verge of being lynched.
Now that i think about it, you could be doing reverse psychology to make us think that you don?t have a killing role. I don?t know why you would joke about a solf claiming like this, because there was really no reason to say it.
Irrelavant topic when everyone was scu hunting and questioning. If this was while everyone was shtposting that?s understandable, but it really seems like you?re just trying to change the topic when people where talking about you.
Really being defensive, pretty rash defense. little salty comment on Ness.
No it?s not, roleclaiming on day 1 is just asking to get killed/role blocked. You have other ways of defending yourself, roleclaiming this early should really be a last ditch effort.
This is just silly, voting for someone you think is innocent to save your skin only hurts town. If you want to live, wolf hunt, bring up a case, try to defend yourself further. You just look like you?re giving up. You probably haven?t wolf hunted because you?re scared of being blamed and lynched for the flip.
Overall, Haydenn is my priority lynch, I?m pretty sure he?s either Wolf/Yeti. He get?s my vote today.
Sarnone-Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that
Jellofish- Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that.
Reyy-Hasn?t posted much, can?t read for that. However, i did find this quote to be weird
This looks really fake, they say they have doubts, but are just going to dismiss it? If you are suspicious of something(Starry in this case) point it out and say why it?s weird, seems like they want to show that they have suspicions on someone, makes it seem like you are pointing out a weird post to help town, but want her to like you for not pressing her. This is only one post though so i can?t go with much else against them.
These 4 people have just been really inactive, which is okay for newbies on Day 1.But later as the games goes on, being inactive starts to get very suspicious, so I want to hear more from you all.
Enderwiggin- Pretty quiet as of now. I know you said you said i was wolf at the very beginning, voted for me, and then said i?m wolf again. But you haven?t made a case on me, so i just dismissed it as you trying to see if i freak out or something like that. Not enough posts to read from though. But i?m acknowledging your suspicions, but until i see a case on me i can?t really do much about it.
Dolby- He hasn?t posted a whole lot, but was the first to bring up the case of Haydenn. While i don?t think Haydenn?s case had much merit, his reaction and behavior so far is pretty weird. Overall just helping town.
Lucanosa- You?re pretty weird to read, you have posted every once in awhile, but your posts don?t really help town. You?re relatively new to mafia, so maybe you don?t know how to wolf hunt yet, but I don?t think anything you?ve said is too wolfy. I would however, like to hear your thoughts and opinions whenever you get to reading the game properly.
Blu Rose- I haven?t played with you much outside of tiny quick games, so i don?t really know your playstyle. You overall seem to not really help town, but haven?t said anything wolfy. You seem like a good player so i?m thinking you're just reading and waiting to make a good case, so nothing wolfy to me so far.
Ayaya- New player, but surprisingly brought up suspicions on someone Jacob, another newbie even. You stray from the other inactives newbies in the fact that you started a case on someone. But it?s not the strongest case i?ve seen, you seem pretty off to me in not just bandwagoning. Either you?re just bold,or you had a team telling you what to do? Not my priority suspicion but I want to make note of it.
Ashot- He is pretty hard to read in games i play with him, he always sht posts no matter what alignment. I find it weird how he wants to lynch Starry just because ?I don?t like her? but it?s only day one and i don?t think he would be saying wolfy stuff like that as mafia, especially from an experienced member. I think you?re town as of now.
Tom- He tends to immediately go from Sht posting to serious posting when he?s mafia. I haven?t seen any wolfy posts here, but he has the behavior of wolf. You even saying "Let me finish sht posting" stuck me as odd too, You are usually very hard to read, which makes me always wonder whether or not you're mafia.
Trojan- The wildcard like always. You switch from silly to serious, typical playstyle of town trojan. I do find your pms to people a bit odd though. Maybe you?re just trying to get reactions and thoughts from the otherwise quiet newbies, but i?ve never seen you do this before it raises an eyebrow.
Starrywolf- Inactive like always, i know you have boarding school or something like that so i don?t find it suspicious anymore. However, the one post you did do was you pushing your town claim again. You did it in smash mafia when you were mafia, so i don?t think you would make that mistake again as mafia. I think your town so far, but since you are kinda acting like you did as mafia in smash, won?t completely dismiss it.
Jacob- You seem to excuse yourself a lot, in almost all your post you say stuff like ?Oh sorry i was busy doing something/I will post later/making excuses? when it?s not really needed. Being a new player, it could just be your fear of people being suspicious of you for being inactive, but you have yet to say any thoughts you have so far. I?m reading more noob playing than anything else though.
N e s s- Trying to scum hunt this whole game, maybe too hard, but that?s what he usually does so it doesn?t surprise me. You used traps that don?t really make sense in the DA:I mafia game, and you were mafia. Still don?t get why you set a trap for tom and tom alone. But you were pressing really hard on some people so i don?t think wolves would be the ones to start a bandwagon like that because when they flip they get the blame. Leaning more towards town but i could see you as mafia.
Haydenn- While i believe Dolby?s case on you is rather weak, i find your reaction to it and behavior afterwards to be very interesting. Here are some quotes and my reaction to it:
This was from very early in the day, when the Starry wagon was starting. I find it weird that you would suggest forcing someone to claim so early in day one, when she wasn?t on the verge of being lynched.
Now that i think about it, you could be doing reverse psychology to make us think that you don?t have a killing role. I don?t know why you would joke about a solf claiming like this, because there was really no reason to say it.
Irrelavant topic when everyone was scu hunting and questioning. If this was while everyone was shtposting that?s understandable, but it really seems like you?re just trying to change the topic when people where talking about you.
Really being defensive, pretty rash defense. little salty comment on Ness.
No it?s not, roleclaiming on day 1 is just asking to get killed/role blocked. You have other ways of defending yourself, roleclaiming this early should really be a last ditch effort.
This is just silly, voting for someone you think is innocent to save your skin only hurts town. If you want to live, wolf hunt, bring up a case, try to defend yourself further. You just look like you?re giving up. You probably haven?t wolf hunted because you?re scared of being blamed and lynched for the flip.
Overall, Haydenn is my priority lynch, I?m pretty sure he?s either Wolf/Yeti. He get?s my vote today.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Erm.
1. Did you read the roleclaim?
2. Did you read the roleclaim?
3. Did you read the roleclaim?
- - - Post Merge - - -
You were right about my poke at you tho.
1. Did you read the roleclaim?
2. Did you read the roleclaim?
3. Did you read the roleclaim?
- - - Post Merge - - -
You were right about my poke at you tho.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2014
- Posts
- 13,849
- Bells
- 1,008
- Sautéed Mushrooms
- 0
- Spores
- 0
- Switch
- 0804-8939-7771
- Island
- Sandoval
Yeah i just did and I'm thinking about it right now, I don't think it's that though. Tanking a hit is a pretty risky trick and I wouldn't expect it from Haydenn. I really just think it's a ploy to screw with our minds and not vote, like i see happening now.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
...
That moment when you want to go back to your pet theory.
That moment when you want to go back to your pet theory.
Ya know Dannyboy, i've said neumerous times that i didn't intend on it being just Tom but everyone so...
Also that Tom was calling Blu Rose out as wolf on a not very wolf post which i've also explained numerous times...
...Did you even read the thread? Because Haydenn is the coward...
- - - Post Merge - - -
Uh huh...you sure about that
Also that Tom was calling Blu Rose out as wolf on a not very wolf post which i've also explained numerous times...
...Did you even read the thread? Because Haydenn is the coward...
- - - Post Merge - - -
Uh huh...you sure about that
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Can't decide if normal Daniel or actual wolf.
Can a role not show up in game as well?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Could be both.
Jacob
Senior Member
I am a little confused, if Haydenn is coward, that would beneficial for town right?
but anyway
at first i didn't but now I actually believe haydenn is Coward because I am assuming there is only one of them
no one else was like "bruh how r u coward i am coward"
but anyway
at first i didn't but now I actually believe haydenn is Coward because I am assuming there is only one of them
no one else was like "bruh how r u coward i am coward"
Jacob multipludes of people can have the same role, so thats not valid.
Alright, i'm putting my vote on Daniel. His reasoning for lynching Haydenn when he just voted for him is complete BS in my eyes.