Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[FireNinja1]

Oh, I understood you said it as River making an argument in order to defend you and Mary. I didn't know you meant she couldn't save you both.

She made two separate arguments to save both of us, which was, ultimately, her downfall.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

She made two separate arguments to save both of us, which was, ultimately, her downfall.

That just screamed "I'm Mafia/Townie and they are too!" Not the best move.

 

[BellGreen]

1) Mistakes can bring light to information that can be used for Town players. Like I said before we need to get information out of people & any events such as lynching. We are the uninformed majority and we need to seek every possible way to get our hands on information that will lead us to Mafia members. Mistakes should not be ignored.

2) This, I can see happening on the Mayor's solo Lynch on Day One. If people aren't posting, then the mayor will have to somehow come to terms & think for themselves. Criticism is apart of the job, no doubt. If the Town can pull together & help the Mayor out, then hopefully we won't be turning against each other very early on.

One of the reasons why I'd probably dislike being mayor, lol. It looks like a great responsibility, but I feel like the solo lynch kind of symbolizes how the mayor will use their powers later on.

- - - Post Merge - - -

That just screamed "I'm Mafia/Townie and they are too!" Not the best move.

That was about the previous game so it's a bit hard to call it a best/worst move.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

One of the reasons why I'd probably dislike being mayor, lol. It looks like a great responsibility, but I feel like the solo lynch kind of symbolizes how the mayor will use their powers later on.

- - - Post Merge - - -



That was about the previous game so it's a bit hard to call it a best/worst move.

Yeah, but review. A Mafia wouldn't save a Townie or the other way around so basically, it wasn't. It led to everyone knowing River was on Mary and Fire's side.

 

[FireNinja1]

I urge all of you to think before you vote. There is only a 63% chance that both the mayor and sheriff will be innocent, if everyone has an equal chance (which, in this case, it's not, but it's just probability).

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah, but review. A Mafia wouldn't save a Townie or the other way around so basically, it wasn't. It led to everyone knowing River was on Mary and Fire's side.

A Townie wouldn't save a Townie. Remember that they don't know who each other are, and if they know they're innocent, they don't want to be flipped green/red.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Yeah, I hope the new mayor is a Townie, or the town is dead.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then again, Kayla does enforce the fact she's a Townie a little bit too much...

 

[BlueLeaf]

Just a note: I'll end up voting for someone who isn't currently the most popular candidate. *cough*Justin*cough* This will tie into my mayoral skills. I will avoid bandwagons let alone start/join one.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I should fix that. People are changing their vote to iLoveYou.

 

[BellGreen]

Yeah, I hope the new mayor is a Townie, or the town is dead.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then again, Kayla does enforce the fact she's a Townie a little bit too much...

What Townie do you mean; the actual role or someone on the Town side? Because any Town player can become mayor, it shouldn't be subjected to just one role.
Although a plain vanilla role would help simplify things.

 

[cannedcommunism]

Yeah, I hope the new mayor is a Townie, or the town is dead.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then again, Kayla does enforce the fact she's a Townie a little bit too much...

A blue player wouldn't be very harmful though, would it?

 

[iLoveYou]

Then again, Kayla does enforce the fact she's a Townie a little bit too much...

I'm saying I'm aligned with the Town. Townie is a whole other role by itself. I'm enforcing that I'm aligned with Town because there's too high of a chance that someone who is scum might get Mayor. Especially watching the votes go in. It's weird that people are getting votes without posting.

 

[BellGreen]

I'm saying I'm aligned with the Town. Townie is a whole other role by itself. I'm enforcing that I'm aligned with Town because there's too high of a chance that someone who is scum might get Mayor. Especially watching the votes go in. It's weird that people are getting votes without posting.

This; Previously said, they may be mafioso so they won't slip like I did on the first day. I wasn't mafia though lol.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Sorry, I meant really anyone in the Town. But like I said, the fact that Kayla enforces her role as a Town member is suspicious. She's attempting to convince everyone she's in the Town.

 

[BellGreen]

This; Previously said, they may be mafioso so they won't slip like I did on the first day. I wasn't mafia though lol.

On the first game anyway

 

[BlueLeaf]

A blue player wouldn't be very harmful though, would it?

The Mad Hatter can basically kill anyone who is not a popular lynch candid. I wouldn't call that safe.

 

[radical6]

Just a note: I'll end up voting for someone who isn't currently the most popular candidate. *cough*Justin*cough* This will tie into my mayoral skills. I will avoid bandwagons let alone start/join one.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I should fix that. People are changing their vote to iLoveYou.

justin was pretty popular before. there was a bandwagon for him earlier so ..?
if anything, VD and SP are unpopular.

 

[Superpenguin]

Just a note: I'll end up voting for someone who isn't currently the most popular candidate. *cough*Justin*cough* This will tie into my mayoral skills. I will avoid bandwagons let alone start/join one.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I should fix that. People are changing their vote to iLoveYou.

Vote who you think will do the best job(yourself included) don't just vote for someone else because you want to avoid a bandwagon. If you think you are joining a bandwagon, just give a reason for your vote. Avoiding bandwagons because you are scared of suspicion is suspicious in itself.

I know this moght not mean anything, but you were the only contributative candidate that hasn't really given any hint to what side you are on.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

During the first days of the Mafia, I don't trust anyone. Kayla, you say you're with the Town, but I won't know. This game is about discovering the Mafia, so I still have suspicions.

 

[iLoveYou]

Because I don't have much to slip up on here, Kippla. =P

 

[Superpenguin]

Sorry, I meant really anyone in the Town. But like I said, the fact that Kayla enforces her role as a Town member is suspicious. She's attempting to convince everyone she's in the Town.

That should really be everybody's goal, especially townies.

 

[cannedcommunism]

The Mad Hatter can basically kill anyone who is not a popular lynch candid. I wouldn't call that safe.

Oh, I forgot about that. But any blue other than that or a vigilante would still be safe, I suppose.