Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[FireNinja1]

Last game, FoxWolf voted for me 11 minutes into Day...2? He then proceeded to say that he didn't know who the mafia was. I don't know his strategy. It's old news SP.

 

[Superpenguin]

Well, I jut wanted to put my suspicions out there early since I won't be on much today.

Happy Thanksgiving!!

 

[FireNinja1]

Well, I jut wanted to put my suspicions out there early since I won't be on much today.

Happy Thanksgiving!!

Same. I'll be here all morning, part of the afternoon, and then I'm headed to my neighbors for some thanksgiving dinner. We're bring apple pie.

In relevant things, BlueLeaf is a little suspicious to me. He's doing everything that a mafia should do.

 

[Prof Gallows]

I'll be gone here in a couple of hours as well. Have a good day everyone. Except for whoever gets killed.

Sounds like a pretty bad deal, yo.

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Happy start of Hanukkah and Thanksgiving~ (Hanuksgivng?) Anyway, I'll be in Texas all day, so I don't know how active I'll be. Still keeping up with the game!

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Good morning and happy Thanksgiving! Reading through those pages took a while.

I think that anyone who voted suspiciously or silently should speak up now. Staying silent won't benefit you or your side.

 

[iLoveYou]

Thank you for giving me the chance as Sheriff everyone.

So the name I'd like to bring up again is Beary509. We discussed her a little bit during the elections. She is a confirmed bandwagoner (poor gameplay due to being a newbie or not?). Being that it is Day One, this lynch will be a complete hit or miss. We all know that. If we do not feel like we have a lead by the end of today, we can look at people like Beary509. It's just a suggestion, and I would appreciate it if the Town can input on their thoughts of Beary509 so we can try to narrow down whether she is guilty or not.

I personally think it was more of a newbie mistake rather than something suspicious though. Bandwagoners are still dangerous though, as they can influence bad lynching (lynching of innocents).

Detectives:

Again I'm going to bring up Mafia Framers. The Mafia have been reading this thread, they have the ability to frame these two powerful positions, especially now that one is someone who has stood out for negative reasons (Me). I have a huge feeling Mafia will target me & frame me Night One as they probably know there's a great chance for us to be inspected. Remember that Mafia (not knowing who the bodyguards are) are going to try to find an easier way to get the Mayor + Sheriff out .. what's easier than to have you see us as "Mafia Goon" through framing?

I don't know who the Detectives are, so my only choice here is to do it publicly. Neither am I asking you to reveal yourselves unless you feel 100% confident.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Beary did claim she was new but went out and said that she picked Justin because everyone else was. I'd still keep an eye on her, and inspect her as soon as the Mayor and Sheriff have been. Therefore, she will be inspected on either Day 3 or Day 4, depending on how many detectives we have.

 

[cannedcommunism]

Lynch Kuma ;-D

Any reason why?

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

By the way, why was there a lynch Kuma campaign last game?

 

[cannedcommunism]

By the way, why was there a lynch Kuma campaign last game?

Honestly, I have no idea. She had no particularly suspicious activity, but I guess people were trying to vote her out just for fun.

 

[FireNinja1]

Honestly, I have no idea. She had no particularly suspicious activity, but I guess people were trying to vote her out just for fun.

Not true. She made a "suspicion list".

 

[cannedcommunism]

Not true. She made a "suspicion list".

Everybody does. Even Justin made a suspicion list, and he wasn't mafia. And plus, you were mafia last game.

 

[iLoveYou]

Dolby Right out of the gate, they casted their vote...and it was for Gallows, a candidate that wouldn't even post until about a day later. Dolby is either uninterested in investing time into this game, or they have some other reason.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby also never explained their vote, nor did they bother to post after voting.

Wait! Let me rephrase the whole Dolby thing! It was FoxWolf who voted first out of the gate for Gallows, my mind trailed off to Dolby, sorry. :/ Well, Dolby felt that she started a bandwagon for Justin, and that's all she had to say for the day.

Then she randomly switched to Gallows without explanation before Gallows even began to post in this thread. I want to hear some explanations from Dolby.

I think that anyone who voted suspiciously or silently should speak up now. Staying silent won't benefit you or your side.

This.

A lot of the silent voters are not being active in this thread yet are silently slipping their votes in. How can they judge without participating in the discussion (unless they have a clear view of who their targets are)? I doubt they found the time to read over 40 pages. It would be nice to see a silent voter say hello & explain themselves.

Dolby is one of them, along with Beary509.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I don't know who the Detectives are, so my only choice here is to do it publicly. Neither am I asking you to reveal yourselves unless you feel 100% confident.

This might be a good idea, because then the town knows the Detectives. The Mafia will target them, but considering the Town knows the Detectives, they can pick out the mafiaso easier because the Town wouldn't vote against their own, especially if they know who is a Detective.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think that makes sense, since the Godfather can't pretend in-game to be a Detective. Also, I'm confused on one thing. What does it mean if you are framed? Will you be suddenly accused of being Mafia or something?

 

[Superpenguin]

This might be a good idea, because then the town knows the Detectives. The Mafia will target them, but considering the Town knows the Detectives, they can pick out the mafiaso easier because the Town wouldn't vote against their own, especially if they know who is a Detective.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think that makes sense, since the Godfather can't pretend in-game to be a Detective. Also, I'm confused on one thing. What does it mean if you are framed? Will you be suddenly accused of being Mafia or something?

Mafia can just kill at night. Of course they won't target them at a lynch. That's totally give away who the mafia are.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you get framed, if a detective role checks you that night, you will be returned as mafia goon. If you're my role checked, nothing happens.

 

[iLoveYou]

Being framed means, when a detective choose to inspect you at night then their result will appear that the player has the role of "Mafia Goon". This would lead the detective to think they are a member of the Mafia party. So even if you are a genuine Town role (green/blue), you will appear to the detectives as "Mafia Goon" (red). Only for one night though, since the Mafia Framers (each individually) can not frame you two nights in a row.

 

[Superpenguin]

*not, not "my"

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Oh, thank you.

I almost forgot about Night kills! While they have the chance to kill the Detectives at night upon revealing themselves, they will be safe during the Day because no mafiaso would go for a Detective if they revealed themselves. We just need to protect the Detectives at night, though. They don't need to reveal themselves, it's just an idea.

 

[oath2order]

Okay so uh looks like I have the dreadful responsibility of deciding the lynch today...

Just FYI guys, I won't be able to post much in here until later today so expect a little bit of silence. In the meantime, I ask anyone who has any lynch proposals to step forward, speak, and get some discussion going. I'll read through the thread when I get back later and see what everyone has to say. Personally though, I think probably one of the lurkers if nothing else comes up.

I would also like to hear from Oath regarding that strange BlueLeaf vote that was discussed briefly earlier by Super Penguin and myself.

Oh, okay I thought it was. Just went back and saw otherwise, okay. Either way, the way I responded to the quote is still what I'd honestly do if I had been mayor.

Unless some suspicions pop up, I always felt inclined to get rid of one of these three:

Oath2Order His post and vote for BlueLeaf seemed far too suspicious to me and still does. I'd like to hear from him as well. Speak up!

Dolby Right out of the gate, they casted their vote...and it was for Gallows, a candidate that wouldn't even post until about a day later. Dolby is either uninterested in investing time into this game, or they have some other reason.

And I was going to say Reizo-Trepe because they seemed completely clueless as to what is going on...but apparently they aren't even playing?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby also never explained their vote, nor did they bother to post after voting.

Calm down ya'll. You posting while I'm freakin' asleep. Jesus. Anyways, I've copied and pasted my response from earlier below.

I think I've made up my mind on who I'm voting for. BlueLeaf, you have my vote. I would like to see someone new to the game have the role, and from what I can see, you are the most invested new player thus far. You seem like a reasonable person, you seem clear-headed.

I would vote for AndyB, but throughout last game, I'd been torn between thinking he was mafia or not. It's really hard to tell. I mean no offense, and I'm most certainly not accusing you of anything, it's just this weird vibe I get from you. I mean, with your post telling us to be careful who to elect, my first thought is that you're a townie, making sure that we vote the right way. But then, I feel like you're doing some sort of reverse psychology to get us to vote for you. In addition, I always felt like you know more than you should have for being a townie, but that's just my personal feelings. I'm not voting you for lynch anytime soon, but because it's hard to tell, I won't be voting for you for mayor.

Thus far, it seems like Justin is winning the vote. I would be okay with that. Justin, you know the right person to accuse. You were right about River last game, and you did an excellent job of defending yourself. That being said, I would be perfectly fine if you won, but as I said before, I would like a new player, someone with a clean slate and no judgments on their mind.