Mafia TBT Mafia XII: Mean Girls (GAME OVER THREE WAY TIE)

[Kyuby]

I meant what do guys have for now , like who do you suspect from lol, I see the cases on Jello and staratic and mewmew? claiming to be the millers, last mini mafia game I clamied I was the miller at day one, they still lynched me at day 2 so I wouldnt suggets doing it

 

[Aerious]

jello scum

 

[Sataric]

jello scum

Reminder: As our host PurplPanda has pointed out numerous times already, it is against the rules to edit your posts during the Mafia games. Please pay attention to what you're doing, and play by the rules - A lot of effort goes in to creating a game like this and it's very disrespectful towards PurplPanda and your fellow players to disobey the rules. Thanks.

 

[PurplPanda]

jello scum

Please refrain from editing. Any editing in the future will result in a modkill and a possible ban.

 

[Aerious]

Reminder: As our host PurplPanda has pointed out numerous times already, it is against the rules to edit your posts during the Mafia games. Please pay attention to what you're doing, and play by the rules - A lot of effort goes in to creating a game like this and it's very disrespectful towards PurplPanda and your fellow players to disobey the rules. Thanks.

Thanks for the TL;DR (literally didn't read anything but the first line) but I told him that I bumrushed and put pally and changed my answer. Pce

 

[Princess]

Reminder: As our host PurplPanda has pointed out numerous times already, it is against the rules to edit your posts during the Mafia games. Please pay attention to what you're doing, and play by the rules - A lot of effort goes in to creating a game like this and it's very disrespectful towards PurplPanda and your fellow players to disobey the rules. Thanks.

Last I checked, Purpl was the host, thanks.

 

[Sataric]

Last I checked, Purpl was the host, thanks.

Yeah, I am aware of that. That's exactly what I wrote in my post. I cannot know if he's around 24/7 however - People need to sleep and stuff - So there may sometimes be important for the rest of us to remind the newcomers of breaking the rules, in my opinion. Else they might end up ruining Purpl's game that he's put tons of time and effort into, which I think is very disrespectful.

 

[Byngo]

I meant what do guys have for now , like who do you suspect from lol, I see the cases on Jello and staratic and mewmew? claiming to be the millers, last mini mafia game I clamied I was the miller at day one, they still lynched me at day 2 so I wouldnt suggets doing it

I don't know if it's necessarily a case against Jello, rather I think we'd like to have Jello (hopefully) clear things up. I'm not entirely for lynching Jello because it is very possible they could be a blue role. By Jello replying, we could possibly get a "read" on what role they may have.

Idk what this case about Mew is?? I haven't seen anything about them.

 

[Aerious]

In my experience with mafia, I have only ever seen one miller. Sataric and Alice are both claiming plastic; however, Alice was the one who specified that the role name is Junior Plastic. Sataric never specified that in their first, extremely long post so I'm leaning on him to be a PR or a mafia. Jello is also highly suspicious.

My vote for first lynch is Sataric.

 

[Princess]

Yeah, I am aware of that. That's exactly what I wrote in my post. I cannot know if he's around 24/7 however - People need to sleep and stuff - So there may sometimes be important for the rest of us to remind the newcomers of breaking the rules, in my opinion. Else they might end up ruining Purpl's game that he's put tons of time and effort into, which I think is very disrespectful.

If you literally go a page or two back, Purpl said he can handle it. You don't have to worry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I meant what do guys have for now , like who do you suspect from lol, I see the cases on Jello and staratic and mewmew? claiming to be the millers, last mini mafia game I clamied I was the miller at day one, they still lynched me at day 2 so I wouldnt suggets doing it

What case on Mew? :s


I agree with what Natty has said, I'd really like for Jello to clear up their word choice.
Until we hear from Jello, Sat and Jello are my top choices for today's lynch.

 

[Hikari]

I'm not sure about lynching JelloFishXD, since shooting could amean they're a Vig, since they shot at night. It could also mean they're Mafia tho, since they shot at night as we'll, so it's a 50/50 chance we find scum, if we decide to lynch him. (Unless he tells us why he used the term "shoot", which could help us decide if he's town or mafia.)

 

[Flop]

I'm not sure about lynching JelloFishXD, since shooting could amean they're a Vig, since they shot at night. It could also mean they're Mafia tho, since they shot at night as we'll, so it's a 50/50 chance we find scum, if we decide to lynch him. (Unless he tells us why he used the term "shoot", which could help us decide if he's town or mafia.)

This is why my suspicion is only half-hearted. He seems to be inexperienced and may have just gotten confused, but maybe he let something slip that he didn't want us to know. I'm keeping my eye out, but so far I'm undecided.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

I'm awake finally XD
I'm looking through everything now, i think i missed a lot

 

[fairyring]

as a newbie, is "shoot" specifically a thing only mafia can do, and that's why it's suspicious about jellofish? if that's the case, and only mafia can "shoot" people, i'd definitely think that might be a slip. "lynching" is what townies do, right?

sorry for the questions; just want to make sure i'm on the right track while reading everything. please bear with my newness! xD

 

[Mewmewmewm]

I meant what do guys have for now , like who do you suspect from lol, I see the cases on Jello and staratic and mewmew? claiming to be the millers, last mini mafia game I clamied I was the miller at day one, they still lynched me at day 2 so I wouldnt suggets doing it

Did i miss something? Whats the case on me? I might have missed a page or something somewhere so sorry if thats the case but. . .? Are you confused with another game of mafia?
But the case on jello. See the thing about this is is that i made a similar mistake in my first game of mafia that made me get lynched. After someone died i started to investigate there death. I made a joke saying
"man. . .its hard being a detective sometimes. . . *blows smoke*"
And then everyone instantly thought i was the detective when i wasn't. I didn't mean that i was the detective in the slightest, however everyone still thought i was. Then people started to suspect me because of that and i got lynched and flipped townie. Considering jellos a new player do you think this might've been the case with them?
But the thing that gets me is that jello isn't responding to any of this. Maybe they just haven't got to it yet or maybe they're not sure of how to respond to all of this. I'd like to hear their input before i decide to lynch them. I rather not lynch someone with the possibility of a blue role.

 

[Stevey Queen]

Wooh! Finished reading everything. The only person I have a suspicion on is JeloFish

Here he said "shoot". The only people who can shoot are vigs and Mafia. This might be a simple typo but, I'm watching you.

Does shoot mean something different then lynch? And what's a vig?

^ n00b alert

 

[Blu Rose]

I really don't know why you guys are looking to much into the wording of JelloFish's post.

Honestly, you guys are all paying attention to the first part, with shooting

I'd say either go for them or go a Inactive Lynch I'm Rly afraid of shooting

But then he also said this directly after.

Alice and Sataric because they have a chance of being town we can trust them or lynch

He's worrying about shooting them due to a possibility of them being town.

So why look into the wording too much?

Besides, there are a few flaws with JelloFish being Mafia...

1.) S/he wouldn't have full control over kills, they'd have to reach a full consent from everyone in the Mafia first.
2.) Would not the Mafiosi want to keep around distractions so that attention won't shift to them?

Honestly, JelloFish wouldn't be a wise first lynch.
Blue massacre much, y'all?

But seriously though, JelloFish isn't a good lynch.

If, and only if, JelloFish is a Vig, we'll just get him/her to shoot an inactive or someone s/he suspects tonight. Then we can truly figure out who to lynch tomorrow.

Also, if there is a Voyeur this game, or a person that can check what happened to a person, I encourage you to check JelloFish tonight...

But, as of now, we should probably lynch an inactive since no one has a suspicion that they have felt is worth mentioning.

 

[radical6]

Does shoot mean something different then lynch? And what's a vig?

^ n00b alert

A vig is a town player who can kill someone at night. Usually vigs only have 1 shot, so they can only kill one person. (If their kill isn't blocked). Though some times there can be 2 shot vigs, 3 shot vigs, etc.

 

[Gingersnap]

I think until we hear Jello's side of the story, they will end up getting my vote for lynching.
From what other people have stated, they have been in one or two mafias, so the confusion between "shoot" and "lynch" is noew highly unlikely.
At least from my perspective that is.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

Does shoot mean something different then lynch? And what's a vig?

^ n00b alert

Shoot means that they would kill them using a night action. This power is usually given to the mafia, however some blue roles also have this power.
Lynch means to get a majority vote on someone to kill them. Everyone puts in their vote and whoever has the most votes gets lynched.
A vig is a townie who can kill a player at night.