Mafia TBT Mafia XII: Mean Girls (GAME OVER THREE WAY TIE)

[Gingersnap]

Mew is making a lot of sense. Would it be a waste of a night to inspect Jello to find out what she really is?
Is the lynching just going to end up being an inactive?

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

I'm working on a list of em right now lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

feloreena, crazy-gamer, alise, beardo, and kyuby -
i feel like there are a bunch of inactives but these people
haven't put an a stance at all.

Yeah sorry about being inactive this is my 1st game and I have no clue what to say ;-;

 

[fairyring]

Yeah sorry about being inactive this is my1s game and I have no clue what to say ;-;

just try to contribute an opinion here or there! i personally don't feel super strongly in any particular way since it's only the first day but i'm still making a point to post so people know i'm here haha.

 

[Byngo]

Mew is making a lot of sense. Would it be a waste of a night to inspect Jello to find out what she really is?
Is the lynching just going to end up being an inactive?

I don't think it would be a waste. If we don't find their role quickly, we could be left still wondering what role they may be - and that will just divide people up. I think it's be best to find out there role ASAP.

If we're going the inactive route, I think we should all determine who we should lynch. I'm having trouble looking through the list and picking out any names to consider. Idk, it's just that most of the names in the list are either players that are usually active or noobs, and I don't think it's fair to lynch any of them. The only name I can come up with is MissNoodle, and that's a stretch... They've been more active recently. :<

 

[Pathetic]

TinyTaylor @ mostly because I might be a little inactive this game but lynching me would be a really bad mistake for town, js.
Sorry I haven't been contributing, I'm not even supposed to be on the computer atm.

 

[tinytaylor]

Mew is making a lot of sense. Would it be a waste of a night to inspect Jello to find out what she really is?
Is the lynching just going to end up being an inactive?

I agree with keeping sataric and alice. I mean the fact they came out with
the same role and there are over 30 people I imagine there will be duplicate
roles. On the other hand what if the inactive people are innocent? I'm pretty
much torn at this point, if we go no lynch we risk 3 townies being killed. If we
lynch there's a large possibility the lynchee is town.

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

Yeah sorry about being inactive this is my 1st game and I have no clue what to say ;-;

Crape forgot not to edit my bad!

 

[Alice]

Just by looking at all of the information about sataric and Alice, i REALLY don't think they should be lynched. I have full faith in Alice on one hand because of the fact that she knew the exact name of the role in a closed game setup. Not to mention there is no way a mafia player would draw attention to themselves this early, it just doesn't make sense to me that they're mafia. I think we should just go for the inactive for now. I'd rather not lynch Jello because there is a slim chance we might be killing off a vig or a blue who could really help us.

I don't think I've ever seen mafia use the term "shoot" before, so lynching Jello would be a long stretch.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I agree with keeping sataric and alice. I mean the fact they came out with
the same role and there are over 30 people I imagine there will be duplicate
roles. On the other hand what if the inactive people are innocent? I'm pretty
much torn at this point, if we go no lynch we risk 3 townies being killed. If we
lynch there's a large possibility the lynchee is town.

It doesn't matter if the inactive people are innocent. If they don't answer to PM prodding, they're useless.

 

[radical6]

I agree with keeping sataric and alice. I mean the fact they came out with
the same role and there are over 30 people I imagine there will be duplicate
roles. On the other hand what if the inactive people are innocent? I'm pretty
much torn at this point, if we go no lynch we risk 3 townies being killed. If we
lynch there's a large possibility the lynchee is town.

An inactive townie isn't any good at all, tbh. We will just be worrying if they're going to be modkilled, replaced, or if they're just scum sliding by.

I don't think I've ever seen mafia use the term "shoot" before, so lynching Jello would be a long stretch.
It doesn't matter if the inactive people are innocent. If they don't answer to PM prodding, they're useless.

Yeah, scum usually uses the term "kill" instead. I'm more inclined to believe that Jellofish is town.

Though like I said earlier in the game not many names on the player list pop out as inactive to me. 8floor has only posted once but they're a newbie so maybe give them a few hours? Natty mentioned MissNoodle as well, but MissNoodle has a different timezone so maybe we can wait for her.

 

[Sataric]

Yeah, I just want to quickly explain that part of the reason you'd vote out an inactive player is because if they aren't really playing the game anyways you will always wonder if perhaps they could be scum, yet they would provide no benefits or help to the town team. It's the safest path to take on Day 1 when you have very little to go on. Even if you do end up killing an innocent, the loss is not overwhelmingly negative because they wouldn't really have been playing either way. However, I feel like PurplPanda is really quick to sort out any issues, and that it's likely he would replace inactive players with active ones over time. So I'm really not sure what to do at this point.

Yui Z is normally more vocal than she has been so far. However, she might be working with people behind the scenes. She does that often as far as I know and she's an excellent and highly underrated player. I don't want to risk misslynching her because it'd be a big loss for town if she's innocent. We should keep an eye on her, though.

Prin suggesting that we should waste time inspecting the Millers is honestly giving me scummy vibes. Either you trust us or you do not. If you do not, then you shouldn't keep us around, but it's honestly very unlikely that a Mafia member would do something so stupid as to roleclaim on Day 1. And inspecting us will show us flagged as Mafia anyways, since us Millers are essentially permanently framed? So if you have doubts to begin with, there would still be doubts afterwards. Feels like Prin is trying to waste our most important roles time and I do not agree with it one bit.

Kyuby's posts so far are completely lacking in real content and depth - He either agrees with what someone else has just posted or essentially just wastes time, asking people to "get back on topic" even when nobody was discussing anything that was not related to the game. Very strange.

And my final comment for right now - Dolby has often been lynched Day 1 because he is scary when he's scum (Blue sniper and all!) but I feel that he proved himself in Bird Mafia to be really strong even when on the town team. Keep a close eye on him. He's tricky and very good at what he does. However, I think we'd be foolish to get rid of him Day 1 yet again, personally. If he's town, he'll be a valuable asset.

 

[tinytaylor]

I don't think I've ever seen mafia use the term "shoot" before, so lynching Jello would be a long stretch.

- - - Post Merge - - -



It doesn't matter if the inactive people are innocent. If they don't answer to PM prodding, they're useless.

I was just looking through other threads and I stumbled across this one:
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?181574-TBT-Main-Mafia-XI-Person-of-Interest-END

The three people shot were townies, all shot day one.
This game (like the other) was made by Tom, so I have a feeling
shooting is an action commited by mafia.

 

[radical6]

I was just looking through other threads and I stumbled across this one:
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?181574-TBT-Main-Mafia-XI-Person-of-Interest-END

The three people shot were townies, all shot day one.
This game (like the other) was made by Tom, so I have a feeling
shooting is an action commited by mafia.

Tom used both terms though. But the idea of shooting is more of a vig thing? Like when people talk about shooting it can mean mafia too, but they will use the term "killing" instead. Most scum chats say they're going to kill instead of shoot anyway.

 

[Feloreena]

feloreena, crazy-gamer, alise, beardo, and kyuby -
i feel like there are a bunch of inactives but these people
haven't put an a stance at all.

Your list is missing a fair amount of inactives. Why do you leave the other players out..?

I'll just run through some of my thoughts before I sleep on things that have been discussed. I won't support a lynch on Alice or Sataric, I feel that the information they have both been able to provide has cleared both of their names. I think anyone that is still going to try and push a lynch on them is going to come off as scummy or not fully understanding what a Miller is in this game.

I am sure Jellofish will clear anything up from his posts earlier (timezones and such), but the word shoot to me implies Vigilante instead of Mafia based on language used in other games. Don't really feel that that is solid evidence to lynch anyone yet, there's still a fair bit of time left in the day and plenty more people need to contribute.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

Yeah, I just want to quickly explain that part of the reason you'd vote out an inactive player is because if they aren't really playing the game anyways you will always wonder if perhaps they could be scum, yet they would provide no benefits or help to the town team. It's the safest path to take on Day 1 when you have very little to go on. Even if you do end up killing an innocent, the loss is not overwhelmingly negative because they wouldn't really have been playing either way. However, I feel like PurplPanda is really quick to sort out any issues, and that it's likely he would replace inactive players with active ones over time. So I'm really not sure what to do at this point.

Yui Z is normally more vocal than she has been so far. However, she might be working with people behind the scenes. She does that often as far as I know and she's an excellent and highly underrated player. I don't want to risk misslynching her because it'd be a big loss for town if she's innocent. We should keep an eye on her, though.

Prin suggesting that we should waste time inspecting the Millers is honestly giving me scummy vibes. Either you trust us or you do not. If you do not, then you shouldn't keep us around, but it's honestly very unlikely that a Mafia member would do something so stupid as to roleclaim on Day 1. And inspecting us will show us flagged as Mafia anyways, since us Millers are essentially permanently framed? So if you have doubts to begin with, there would still be doubts afterwards. Feels like Prin is trying to waste our most important roles time and I do not agree with it one bit.

Kyuby's posts so far are completely lacking in real content and depth - He either agrees with what someone else has just posted or essentially just wastes time, asking people to "get back on topic" even when nobody was discussing anything that was not related to the game. Very strange.

And my final comment for right now - Dolby has often been lynched Day 1 because he is scary when he's scum (Blue sniper and all!) but I feel that he proved himself in Bird Mafia to be really strong even when on the town team. Keep a close eye on him. He's tricky and very good at what he does. However, I think we'd be foolish to get rid of him Day 1 yet again, personally. If he's town, he'll be a valuable asset.

I agree. The worst thing that can happen if we lynch an inactive is that we lose an unhelpful townie. But there is a small chance we might get a blue, which is a little scary. However i feel like if someone were a blue they would contribute more so they could know who to investigate and such.
Also i just realized by you saying that, Yui is quite quiet at the moment. Usually shes really talkative, not just in mafia either. But then again, i don't think we should sharpen our pitchforks just because of that.
I feel like we're grasping at strings here, but at the moment i'd probably lynch the person who has been the most inactive just because they're really not helping us advance or contribute to conversations at all.

 

[Beardo]

Hello! I've been away all day, and I'm exhausted >.< Just like to post something before I go to sleep.

 

[tinytaylor]

Tom used both terms though. But the idea of shooting is more of a vig thing? Like when people talk about shooting it can mean mafia too, but they will use the term "killing" instead. Most scum chats say they're going to kill instead of shoot anyway.

this is my first mafia sorry, I need a refresher of what vigilant is.

Your list is missing a fair amount of inactives. Why do you leave the other players out..?

I'll just run through some of my thoughts before I sleep on things that have been discussed. I won't support a lynch on Alice or Sataric, I feel that the information they have both been able to provide has cleared both of their names. I think anyone that is still going to try and push a lynch on them is going to come off as scummy or not fully understanding what a Miller is in this game.

I am sure Jellofish will clear anything up from his posts earlier (timezones and such), but the word shoot to me implies Vigilante instead of Mafia based on language used in other games. Don't really feel that that is solid evidence to lynch anyone yet, there's still a fair bit of time left in the day and plenty more people need to contribute.

This list was for players who hadn't given't their stance.

 

[radical6]

this is my first mafia sorry, I need a refresher of what vigilant is.

A vig is a town player who can kill someone at night. Usually vigs only have 1 shot, so they can only kill one person. (If their kill isn't blocked). Though some times there can be 2 shot vigs, 3 shot vigs, etc.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Vig

SP has been kinda quiet as well but he is in another mafia game so

 

[Alice]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Vig

SP has been kinda quiet as well but he is in another mafia game so

He's a little quiet in that game too.

 

[radical6]

He's a little quiet in that game too.

Yeah I guess. Idk like in Tom's game he was pretty active on day 1 (though he was ****posting for a bit but then he got serious) but he changes his playstyle a lot so i dunno??

When does day end????

 

[PurplPanda]

Yeah sorry about being inactive this is my 1st game and I have no clue what to say ;-;

Crape forgot not to edit my bad!

Since you are new, I will let it slide by. But one more edit, and you will be replaced, unless I get a mod to check it(which I will only do if I am feeling real real generous).

However, I feel like PurplPanda is really quick to sort out any issues, and that it's likely he would replace inactive players with active ones over time. So I'm really not sure what to do at this point.

Inactives will be taken care of as soon as I notice they are inactive.

Yeah I guess. Idk like in Tom's game he was pretty active on day 1 (though he was ****posting for a bit but then he got serious) but he changes his playstyle a lot so i dunno??

When does day end????

Tomorrow at roughly 7ish PM EST.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Fancy timer now up, thanks to Alice!