Mafia TBT Mafia XII: Mean Girls (GAME OVER THREE WAY TIE)

[Aerious]

Your list is missing a fair amount of inactives. Why do you leave the other players out..?

I'll just run through some of my thoughts before I sleep on things that have been discussed. I won't support a lynch on Alice or Sataric, I feel that the information they have both been able to provide has cleared both of their names. I think anyone that is still going to try and push a lynch on them is going to come off as scummy or not fully understanding what a Miller is in this game.

I am sure Jellofish will clear anything up from his posts earlier (timezones and such), but the word shoot to me implies Vigilante instead of Mafia based on language used in other games. Don't really feel that that is solid evidence to lynch anyone yet, there's still a fair bit of time left in the day and plenty more people need to contribute.

In every Mafia game, there has only been one Miller present. The fact that Alice cleared up what the specific title (Junior Plastic) is made it clear that she's actually inno. Sataric I'm not too sure about. Honestly sounded like he just hopped on the bandwagon and made a bunch of garbage up to prove his innocence.

 

[Feloreena]

What's the point of wasting time trying to tell people to agree? I had just skimmed through the thread, trying to make the deadline so I wouldnt be replaced.

May I ask why you had a deadline and other players didn't?

 

[toastia]

May I ask why you had a deadline and other players didn't?

A deadline to be replaced.

 

[f11]

I don't know if this does anything but in chat yesterday Aerious put that they told their role to Pally. Possible scum buddies? So I can see were Dolby's coming from with that Suspicion on Aerious. They also said "Sataric maf". I'd like to hear Aerious talk some more.

 

[Dolby]

In every Mafia game, there has only been one Miller present. The fact that Alice cleared up what the specific title (Junior Plastic) is made it clear that she's actually inno. Sataric I'm not too sure about. Honestly sounded like he just hopped on the bandwagon and made a bunch of garbage up to prove his innocence.

There have been multiple millers in mafia two, three, and eight

 

[Superpenguin]

Everyone thinks we should lynch an inactive. Pally suggested we lynch oath2order.
Mkay

 

[Stevey Queen]

Why does everyone use the word scum?

 

[toastia]

Why does everyone use the word scum?

because it's mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

Everyone thinks we should lynch an inactive. Pally suggested we lynch oath2order.
Mkay

Where's that post at?

 

[f11]

Why does everyone use the word scum?

Scum means Mafia.

 

[Superpenguin]

It was said in the IRC.

 

[Feloreena]

A deadline to be replaced.

Yes, I understand that. I meant more why you were the only one given this deadline, when there were still other players who hadn't posted by the time Purplpanda issued this in the thread.

 

[Aerious]

I don't know if this does anything but in chat yesterday Aerious put that they told their role to Pally. Possible scum buddies? So I can see were Dolby's coming from with that Suspicion on Aerious. They also said "Sataric maf". I'd like to hear Aerious talk some more.

My role isn't any of your business if you weren't in IRC when I claimed it. I actually told Pally on Skype and it's really not a big deal but ok u r 2 gud at dis gaem 4 mi tellin friend mi role!!!!

 

[PurplPanda]

Why does everyone use the word scum?

Scum is any team that is against Town.

 

[toastia]

Yes, I understand that. I meant more why you were the only one given this deadline, when there were still other players who hadn't posted by the time Purplpanda issued this in the thread.

Ask Purpl that, not me.

 

[Alice]

Scum means Mafia.

Actually, not quite. Scum is any party that is not town. It can mean Mafia, Cult, SK's, Fools, etc.

 

[Sataric]

In every Mafia game, there has only been one Miller present. The fact that Alice cleared up what the specific title (Junior Plastic) is made it clear that she's actually inno. Sataric I'm not too sure about. Honestly sounded like he just hopped on the bandwagon and made a bunch of garbage up to prove his innocence.

I tried to explain my reasoning for leaving out the exact role name in a later post, though - Quoted for your convenience:

There was a reason for this, though - I don't know anything about Mean Girls but I read that the plastics were the bad guys, so the role of "Junior Plastic" did sound kind of shady, but that's what PurplPanda choose to call it and it's out of my control. Miller is a role that is common in Mafia, and it's the label that people recognize, so I went with that. Furthermore, by not giving away every single piece of information in the role PM, Alice was able to confirm that she had the same role, winning my trust. I figured that there might be one more Miller since the game is quite large. I now know almost for certain that she is telling the truth.

You seem very bloodthirsty and quick to call people out, which is rather suspicious in itself. Furthermore, you provide no real reasoning for your actions thus far. "Jello Scum" is not exactly the most valuable post in the thread, and I got the impression earlier on that you are trying to vote me out for personal reasons rather than because you think I might be Mafia. That's really scummy in my eyes - Almost as if you don't really care who dies, as long as it's not you. Also, I was the first to claim Miller and I had the right name of the role that I would show up as (Showing up as Karen Smith(Mafia Goon) to any inspections) . Alice confirmed this, that she had the exact same message. Pretty small odds of getting that exactly right if I was anything other than a Miller, don't you think?

 

[toastia]

My role isn't any of your business if you weren't in IRC when I claimed it. I actually told Pally on Skype and it's really not a big deal but ok u r 2 gud at dis gaem 4 mi tellin friend mi role!!!!

Please use proper grammer. I didnt understand a word you just said.

 

[Aerious]

Please use proper grammer. I didnt understand a word you just said.

You're not supposed to, it's me being sarcastic.

 

[f11]

Actually, not quite. Scum is any party that is not town. It can mean Mafia, Cult, SK's, Fools, etc.

Oops, well, thank you for clearing it up for me!

 

[Gingersnap]

After reading Yui-Z's note taking, I'd like to throw in a little defense against the claims made against myself.

So basically at the beginning of the whole Jello debacle I agreed that they are kinda suspicious for mixing up lynch and shoot, and I didn't trust them all too well. After other users began to post as to why Jello made that now confirmed mistake, it made more sense to me why it was made in the first place.

They (being other users) provided good evidence defending against Jellos false framing and I started to agree with their opinions and theories. So that's why I changed my view on the whole ordeal.