Mafia TBT Mafia XII: Mean Girls (GAME OVER THREE WAY TIE)

Okay sorry I haven't been talking, my internet has been **** lately.

I think Jer/Prin is probably the cult leader. It has to be someone experienced anyway, because Yui Z was targeted night one for cult conversion. (Don't think a newbie player would go after Yui since she was thought to be as inactive) Night two I believe it was probably Oath, though he was protected apparently. Night three, I don't know.

So I've been talking to people about Pally/Kaiaa. Kaiaa can't really defend herself against this, but whatever. I've been informed that Pally has claimed "sexually active band geek" before, but she came back as student/townie to an inspection. (Before you ask, I'm not a DT) Pally claimed she was something like a mason, and that there was another sexually active band geek in the game who knows she's town. I don't know why Pally would ever do that, and I hope the person who told me this is telling the truth (if you can confirm Pally told you this please PM me). I think it's likely Pally/Kaiaa is a godfather. There's no reason why Pally would claim she's a mason and a "sexually active band geek" if she was a townie. Lying is scummy. I don't know why she just didn't choose to come back as a twin for godfather inspections, but yeah. She must've forgot or she didn't get to choose. Though I would think inspections would only tell alignment, not roles since this is a closed set up but I'm not sure. If you're Pally's other twin then speak up, otherwise Pally was lying. But she did help a lot to the JellofishXD lynch, though Jellofish kinda outted themself anyway so Pally might've saw that as a chance to gain town's trust.

That and I'm not the only one who's been suspicious of her. I'm kind of surprised some people I've talked to haven't said anything about her, but yeah. Sorry Kaiaa.

I think Natty is cult leader rather than Jer because many things have been contradicted via PM on IRC and you pretty much summed up everything I was thinking about Kaiaa/Pally.
 
Oh scratch what I said about Jer/Prin being cult leader, "mathlete" is just a regular cult member. Still, they came back cult. I don't buy the "but what if the DT is an insane cop" because how would that work? Town comes back as scum? Scum comes back as cult? Cult comes back as town? There's 3 teams. Unless theres actually insane cops in these types of games.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You think Natty is cult leader?? Wait what?
 
Oh scratch what I said about Jer/Prin being cult leader, "mathlete" is just a regular cult member. Still, they came back cult. I don't buy the "but what if the DT is an insane cop" because how would that work? Town comes back as scum? Scum comes back as cult? Cult comes back as town? There's 3 teams. Unless theres actually insane cops in these types of games.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You think Natty is cult leader?? Wait what?

Insane cops get the wrong report. I PM'd you back about it though.
 
Well I don't know about you but I like to work as a team you may see it as bandwagoning but to me is just being a good townie
"Working as a team" is bandwagoning, my dear. Voting for someone just because others are too instead of doing the research and reading the thread yourself makes people seem extremely sus.
 
"Working as a team" is bandwagoning, my dear. Voting for someone just because others are too instead of doing the research and reading the thread yourself makes people seem extremely sus.

It might be scummy to you but that's how I play and you just have to deal with it
 
It might be scummy to you but that's how I play and you just have to deal with it
Solid argument! Clearly you're not guilty! Wow!
Bandwagoning is a **** tactic for people who tend to be lazier players or are trying to stay under the radar.
 
Solid argument! Clearly you're not guilty! Wow!
Bandwagoning is a **** tactic for people who tend to be lazier players or are trying to stay under the radar.

Ok that's what you think
If you think I'm scum vote for me than I don't mind :)
 
Also tsundere, Pally was town but she believed to be mason (she never actually 100% stated mason). Purpl just gave her a role like that because they're friends. Another reason I'm leaning on Natty.
 
I think Natty is mafia, not cult leader. But even if she is town, it's only a matter of time before she is converted to cult because of how many roles she has. And then she will be the most dangerous player in the game. Trundle was in the same situation in Tina's cult game. You guys shouldn't have role claimed so much. Cults can quickly gain power that way. But still, I have reason to believe she is mafia.
 
i am so mad like i sweAR to god if natty.,,,is,,,,scum/cult i am going to cry

ive only rc'ed to like...3 people...(i think? yea) but ive been working with her the entire game and i dont know what to think anymore ugrh
 
If all of you want to vote for me, go ahead. Tbh I'm tired of this game now, but I'll forward my roleclaim list to all the people I trust.

Also, fack you Aerious. Jer is obviously cult and I wouldn't be surprised if you are since you were outed as the vet a long time ago. There haven't been any contradictions at all - just skews of the truth. If, and when I get lynched, you'll obviously want to look at both of them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Aerious and Jer are both cult trying to create as much chaos as possible.

Y'know, it's funny Aerious, that you've been so trusting of people to talk to them for a while and then suddenly **** in them and try to have them voted out of the game. When you did it as town, I thought you were just being an idiot. But it's been a couple days since then, and as far as I know, the vet isn't immune from being recruited. So yeah, you were confirmed town, easy pickings. Of course as scum you'd want to try and get rid of me, knowing my role in this game and how much I've contributed.
 
If all of you want to vote for me, go ahead. Tbh I'm tired of this game now, but I'll forward my roleclaim list to all the people I trust.

Also, fack you Aerious. Jer is obviously cult and I wouldn't be surprised if you are since you were outed as the vet a long time ago. There haven't been any contradictions at all - just skews of the truth. If, and when I get lynched, you'll obviously want to look at both of them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Aerious and Jer are both cult trying to create as much chaos as possible.

Y'know, it's funny Aerious, that you've been so trusting of people to talk to them for a while and then suddenly **** in them and try to have them voted out of the game. When you did it as town, I thought you were just being an idiot. But it's been a couple days since then, and as far as I know, the vet isn't immune from being recruited. So yeah, you were confirmed town, easy pickings. Of course as scum you'd want to try and get rid of me, knowing my role in this game and how much I've contributed.

This. So much this. Jer DOES seem kind of desperate to prove you as scum, simultaneously causing as much mayhem as humanly possible. So either he is cult OR mafia who knows your role trying to get people to lynch you. Both of those are possible. I mean, he DOES have some evidence, but he's almost pushing it. Like I did in Mafia I and III.
 
This. So much this. Jer DOES seem kind of desperate to prove you as scum, simultaneously causing as much mayhem as humanly possible. So either he is cult OR mafia who knows your role trying to get people to lynch you. Both of those are possible. I mean, he DOES have some evidence, but he's almost pushing it. Like I did in Mafia I and III.

Natty and I got into a posting battle and we were both "pushing it". A lot of the evidence the both of us brought forward might not mean anything, but look at the bigger picture. As the debate goes on, you try to put additional smaller evidence forward to see if it makes sense with what other players have noticed, etc.
 
Back
Top