Who is the best (and worst) Sanrio villager and why?

[Plainbluetees]

My pick goes for Toby. He looks so cool and I can’t wait to (possibly) invite him to my island! I’ve wanted him since New Leaf.

The worst would be Rilla. I’m not a huge fan of gorillas to begin with, I honestly think her design would fit a different species a lot better.

 

[Peach_Jam]

It's definitely Etoile for me! Not only is she based on little twin stars (my fav Sanrio characters!), but she's a pastel and dreamy sheep! and her catchphrase is fuzzy so adorablee

as for the worst, I'd pick Rilla because I don't think a gorilla matches well with a hello kitty theme. Also I just think the hello kitty furniture set is a bit on the plain side; it's still cute but it could be better.

 

[Kattea]

In order: Etoile, Chai, Chelsea, Marty, Toby, Rilla

 

[watercolorwish]

Marty is my fave and Chelsea is my least fave. Rilla used to be my least favorite until I just accepted her design is kind of fun and has good references to Hello Kitty. Chelsea is just ugly with that hair, girl what the hell were you thinking

 

[Undies]

Marty, Toby and Etoile are pretty cute - none of them are stay on my island levels though .
I would love to see new villagers; where Keroppi is actually a frog, and Hello Kitty is a cat. Plus there's lots of characters I like more than the ones we got; Choco Cat, Badte Maru, Tuxedo Sam and Pochacco. If they did Aggretsuko I would die for an actual red panda villager over a recoloured squirrel or something haha!.

 

[JessieOfSeacowBay]

Marty, Toby and Etoile are pretty cute - none of them are stay on my island levels though .
I would love to see new villagers; where Keroppi is actually a frog, and Hello Kitty is a cat. Plus there's lots of characters I like more than the ones we got; Choco Cat, Badte Maru, Tuxedo Sam and Pochacco. If they did Aggretsuko I would die for an actual red panda villager over a recoloured squirrel or something haha!.

Agreed! I do like several of the characters, but I love love love Choco Cat! And Pochacco is so cute and a total classic! It might even be interesting to see one of the old characters you don't see stuff for much if at all anymore, like Landry (a crime, Landry was so cute) or Deery Lou.

 

[princess.looking.for.frog]

I love toby’s furniture and Marty‘s design, though we really needed a tuxedosam penguin- ah

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Rilla is the worst omg she's so ugly..why noy use a cat for kitty? The did my Hello Kitty so wrong

 

[Antonio]

The lack of Toby love is insane, he deserves that number one spot. >:C

 

[visibleghost]

best is etoile. second best is chai. then marty.

i don't love rilla because she's a gorilla and i don't like them ):

 

[MuffinTheCat]

My favorite is Chelsea. I have a soft spot for all the deer villagers. When I can I'm definitely going to get her card. My second favorite is Marty because he's just so cute.

 

[ForgottenT]

Étoile is really cute, so I like her.
I'm also a fan of Chelsea.
Toby is my favorite, because of his theme, and I'm contemplating on whether to invite him or not.

 

[juneau]

me and my basic tastes voted Etoile the best, and Rilla is my least favourite as well

I love my current villagers too much to get rid of any of them for Etoile, though, and I really don't need 3 Normals. I did preorder the cards for the furniture.

 

[MuffinTheCat]

me and my basic tastes voted Etoile the best, and Rilla is my least favourite as well

I love my current villagers too much to get rid of any of them for Etoile, though, and I really don't need 3 Normals. I did preorder the cards for the furniture.

Etoile is snooty jsyk

 

[FantasticHaxorus]

toby is simply superior in every way
uhhh worst i dont like marty that much. he seems untrustworthy. also i dont like pudding

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Etoile is snooty jsyk

I’m pretty sure she is a normal (according to nookipedia etc this is what I have seen), but where did you see this? I could be wrong.

 

[michealsmells]

Toby all the way man! I mean come on, you got Keroppi, you got Bnuuy? What's not to love??

Rilla darling I'm sorry but I can't like you no matter how hard I try you're probably so sweet but ;;

 

[Tentacles]

Chai is my fave bc she's adorable, and she reps cinnamoroll so she's completely perfect for me. My least fave is Toby. I'm not into him he just looks off to me.

 

[Garrett]

Best is Marty because he's a lazy, he's yellow, he's a cub, he wears a beret and his furniture is awesome.

Worst is probably Toby. It's the eyes. Those big, round googly eyes! And that haircut doesn't help. Oh, at all. Fab furniture though.

 

[Blueskyy]

Marty is my favorite! I already moved him in with a knock off card I’ve had for a while. I love bear cubs and his little smile and lazy personality is the best. Say what you want about his furniture (the rug) but I love him.

My least favorite is Rilla. I think others who have posted already explained why.

Favorite to least:

Marty
Chai
Étoile
Toby
Chelsea
Rilla