Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Geoni]

There'd be more deaths if she was.

Also my best guess is traitor although having your traitor also be the roleblocker makes it hard for mafia to organize their night-play. But hey we also had that goddamn lightkeeper to our detriment.

 

[Heyden]

There'd be more deaths if she was.

Also my best guess is traitor although having your traitor also be the roleblocker makes it hard for mafia to organize their night-play. But hey we also had that goddamn lightkeeper to our detriment.

Yeah true, unless she's sleeper serial killer but that's stretching. Kermit was specifically KILLED not modkilled.

Also Ryumia where are you pls claim.

 

[Geoni]

- I'm not purposely trying to get everyone's off the mog/tom scum train (choo choo). I just think it's stupid that we are working off of speculation rather than what we have in front of us. Shouldn't we worry about lyncing inactive later on in the game? Why do you keep on backing up fire when he/she can do it themselves?

o**** nevermind fam, he's not my top townread out of the unclear pool anymore after noticing this during a Panda ISO. That is an early on defense of not one but two mafia. Not ready to straight up lynch him over this but Mog in particular didn't even have much heat on her. Tom did though.

- - - Post Merge - - -

these are all leans as of right now:
Vampnessa - nothing about Vanessa says scum to me she seems transparent in her post.
Runeraider - i feel like rune raider is genuinely and actively help us scum hunt and was practically the only person to give Punchy the benefit of the doubt about there weird veteran bomb role.
Kammm -
Ness - he is reminding me completely of his town meta, his emotional back and forth with Toad feels like the town Ness that i know and love.
Amanda -
ILoveYou - first game playing with her, she seems helpful to town but also a bit opprotunistist if that makes sense ? she pushes conversation in a productive way with is good, but haven't seen much actual opinion.
Heyden - seems to be acting his normal town self, but he always seems a bit sus to me so i dont want to exactly town lean him just yet
Evan - i need more from you please.
Dad - up un til recently you have been doing the same this as Glow, so i look forward to hearing more from you and getting a better read on you.
Glow - wish she would post more, she comes in every so often to say a few words then disappears again for the most part.
Ryumia -
Antonio - always seems sus to me, but im starting to learn that, the might just be his personality so not gonna scum lean him yet.
Kermit - the last minute unvote of Punchy seems off to me, then the very vague "i have somethingg to do tonight" i feel like is just a fake soft claim.
Fireninja - at first seemed to come in the thread just to be disruptive and as the game has progressed has kinda faded into the background, maybe starting to feel nervous about standing out as the playlist shrinks ?
GhostKid - i feel like ghosted could be newbie scum slipping under the radar.
Trundle - has been saying far too little for my liking, iirc he use to be more vocal and determined to help scum hunt, but this game he seems t one laying back and letting everything happen around him.

I can look back and develop these more, if i survive tonight, but if i don't please don't let the people that have been popping in and out of the thread just skate by undetected, i believe there's at least one if not more mafia in the people with minimal activity. i love you all and good luck.

What I was meaning to bring back up earlier but I got distracted.

- - - Post Merge - - -

These reads and the Panda ISO in general is coming off as disinterested but her calling people out for skating by is so hypocritical.

 

[Heyden]

Yeah that Antonio quote does look pretty bad but I don't think he's scum still. Panda's reads are a hit or miss imo, not really a pattern

 

[cornimer]

Btw, could doc and watcher say who they were on through the nights?

Locket did no action N1. I was on Kayla N2 (I townread her after the Tom flip, not so much anymore), N3, and I'd rather not say who I was on last night.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*N3 Ness

 

[Chris]

Can mafia use KP on themselves?

Yes.

Reminder to everyone else: if you wish for me to answer a question, use the question colour (demonstrated above). I cannot remark on anything in your posts unless it is specifically directed towards me.

 

[iLoveYou]

I still think our best bet at lynching mafia is within this group:

Amanda / Dad / Ryumia / PandaDarling

I'm leaning between Amanda / PandaDarling / Ryumia for today. All of them were present in the Trundle wagon and voted in the middle / towards the end. At this point the biggest coasters are PandaDarling and Ryumia who are literally voting to stay alive. If Ryumia claims blue it's going to be really hard to believe though. If she claims Townie that would be even harder to believe so it's definitely important that she claims and I'm happy people are starting to finally see that instead of just accusing me of being suspicious over that. Either way she said she feels the mafia knows her role so at this point we need to know it too because why would she left the mafia have an edge over us ? Amanda would be an ideal lynch too because of how hard she pushed for Trundle, but if we're looking at that then so would PandaDarling and Ryumia who set Trundle to be lynched.

 

[Heyden]

Mafia using KP on themselves would make sense though, they’d much rather make today a mislynch rather than a Kermit lynch. But eh idk at this point, Ryumia needs to confirm and stuff.

 

[Ghostkid]

Are we just mas voting panda now?

 

[Heyden]

Are we just mas voting panda now?

I guess so, I don’t reallt think her claim makes sense, idk anout the others

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also can someone find me the post where Rune said Fire was confirmed town through Tina specifically? I don’t doubt Fire but I’m just paranoid

- - - Post Merge - - -

I’ve looked but I can’t all I see is Ness saying it idk

 

[N e s s]

Rune sent this about 30 minutes before EoN3:

Click the post link and it'll show rune's message

 

[iLoveYou]

Mafia using KP on themselves would make sense though, they’d much rather make today a mislynch rather than a Kermit lynch. But eh idk at this point, Ryumia needs to confirm and stuff.

That makes sense. Discussion is only beneficial to Town so why would they want to let it drag on an extra 5 days ( 2 days & one night ).

 

[Geoni]

Locket did no action N1. I was on Kayla N2 (I townread her after the Tom flip, not so much anymore), N3, and I'd rather not say who I was on last night.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*N3 Ness

Why tf wouldn't you say who you were on last night considering they should still have 2 kills? It would confirm another townie. Also how do you know Locket did no action N1 I thought you were a doc?

 

[iLoveYou]

Why tf wouldn't you say who you were on last night considering they should still have 2 kills? It would confirm another townie. Also how do you know Locket did no action N1 I thought you were a doc?

Vampnessa replaced Locket and Tina posted somewhere that all replacements will know the actions of those they are replacing. Other than that I'm not sure why she isn't revealing who she was on last night but at this point I think it's super important to stick to the Trundle wagon.

 

[N e s s]

Vanessa do not reveal who you were on last night

 

[iLoveYou]

Actually it is better for Vanessa not to reveal who she was on so that the mafia can't strategize kills.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tina, would lynching a third party role count as a mislynch ? The question was asked before about modkills I think ?

 

[amanda1983]

--- snip ---

Amanda you've legit been lurking for like 4-5 hours.

I wish ; almost all of that time I would have shown up as "here" was when I was fighting my old phone which kept dying everytime I got back to the thread (tbf it died whenever I did anything, else, too). Finally got the replacement handset at 4:30pm today, and then had to get that up and running. I tried using my iPad again in the interim (once I could sit down) but the battery was almost flat already so that was out, too.

I had already posted here that I was out + busy all day irl, and that I'd be keeping up as much as I could.

--- snip ---

I lowkey feel Ryumia or Amanda has to at least be scum bc Locket/Punchy/Kammm/Ghostkid/Dedenne/Kate/Antonio/Gigablesh all being town would hurt no offence nubs lmao

--- snip ---
Please note:
--- snip ---

• Roles are completely randomised with no human balancing.

Heyden why do are you suggesting scum amongst the new players again - for out-of-game reasons - when we already covered that Tina specifically stated she did NOT do any adjusting to the randomised roles??

 

[Chris]

Actually it is better for Vanessa not to reveal who she was on so that the mafia can't strategize kills.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tina, would lynching a third party role count as a mislynch ? The question was asked before about modkills I think ?

The lynched player must be aligned with the town for it to be considered a mislynch. A non-town death is not a mislynch. I cannot be more specific than this.

 

[iLoveYou]

So Panda is the safest lynch today.

 

[Geoni]

If it clears one of the unclears she should out it, especially if we're not lynching Panda today or No Lynching. Whittling down the pool of unclears is priority. Also Vanessa is obvious kill choice tonight if they're playing it smart and they have been playing the kills smart, at least up until this last night.

Vampnessa replaced Locket and Tina posted somewhere that all replacements will know the actions of those they are replacing. Other than that I'm not sure why she isn't revealing who she was on last night but at this point I think it's super important to stick to the Trundle wagon.

Why just the Trundle wagon? It's lylo, we consider everything.