amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I second the motion
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
I second the motion
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Just what I was looking for, thanks.
idk why you guys think Panda is actually Survivor. She would’ve desperately been breadcrumbing her role flavour and whatnot and she kinda just, gave up.
And Survivor is actually a pretty smart claim bc in all my mafia time here I’ve never seen a Survivor get lynched bc they’re usually believed. But I guess we’re lynching her here bc her death isn’t a threat to town I guess? so
but yeah, friendly neighbour? lawl
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also we can’t speend day unless Ryumia votes so
Fg
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually her flipping Survivor would be more beneficial, fingers crossed!!1
And Survivor is actually a pretty smart claim bc in all my mafia time here I’ve never seen a Survivor get lynched bc they’re usually believed. But I guess we’re lynching her here bc her death isn’t a threat to town I guess? so
but yeah, friendly neighbour? lawl
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also we can’t speend day unless Ryumia votes so
Fg
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually her flipping Survivor would be more beneficial, fingers crossed!!1
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Voting Panda.
amanda1983
Senior Member
Why would Panda flipping Survivor be more beneficial than her flipping Mafia??
amanda1983
Senior Member
Survivors can WIN with either Town or Mafia. They are 3rd party, a seperate faction / alignment to either Town or Mafia.
All 3rd parties are seperate like that, and having a different Win / Con to Town or Mafia factions / alignments.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Thanks
That's pretty much the best group to look at for these lynches. If Ryumia gets modkilled, even better.
idk why Heyden is straight up discounting Antonio but okay.
And I can kinda agree that Panda seems like she is legit survivor townsiding by self-voting if it creates clarity and if she were maf I don't see why she would do that outside of just not wanting to reveal who she aligns with and against any further, but yeah it would bring their KP down when they go from 3 to 2 so the self-vote would be very anti-maf-team.
Also, Vanessa, noted. I don't think I have replaced into a blue on tbt before, just replaced into either a VT or a mafia and their actions are already in a qt. And whatever on the note of who you protected last night, seems like the consensus is a Panda lynch.
Tbh I kinda think it is clearer to me now and the reason I wanted it is because it would say something about Heyden, but Heyden continues to sus her when she is obvious probably. Unless she did panic and mafia just said to hell with their KP and told her to let her lynch herself.
Also lol a Ryumia modkill would kinda help tbh. Her not being around concerns me if just because this is the day I expect even coasty maf to be around.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Anyways bbl
And I can kinda agree that Panda seems like she is legit survivor townsiding by self-voting if it creates clarity and if she were maf I don't see why she would do that outside of just not wanting to reveal who she aligns with and against any further, but yeah it would bring their KP down when they go from 3 to 2 so the self-vote would be very anti-maf-team.
Also, Vanessa, noted. I don't think I have replaced into a blue on tbt before, just replaced into either a VT or a mafia and their actions are already in a qt. And whatever on the note of who you protected last night, seems like the consensus is a Panda lynch.
Tbh I kinda think it is clearer to me now and the reason I wanted it is because it would say something about Heyden, but Heyden continues to sus her when she is obvious probably. Unless she did panic and mafia just said to hell with their KP and told her to let her lynch herself.
Also lol a Ryumia modkill would kinda help tbh. Her not being around concerns me if just because this is the day I expect even coasty maf to be around.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Anyways bbl
Even I am not including him in my list and that's because of Day One voting and how it went down. Mogyay / KermitsTea died mafia. They were more than happy to lynch both Antonio and Dedenne. The Antonio bandwagon was going to happen until a few of us said something about it. Antonio would have been lynched & Mogyay being mafia, it makes more sense to assume she was trying to lynch a Town member on day One.
Why do you keep holding on to Antonio ? I'm genuinely asking in case you see something I don't.
amanda1983
Senior Member
In order of bolded bits from top to bottom :
1. I don't see why it would be anti-Mafia team in this specific case were she Mafia? Mafia KP seems like minor concern, all things considered..
2. I don't understand what you mean by referencing the Panda lynch today in this context sorry? Vanessa is keeping secret who she protected last Night because they weren't targeted so her protecting them doesn't clear them at all ; and to prevent Mafia from knowing what she did, and being able to extrapolate her previous actions into predicting who she'll protect tonight.
3. Could you please restate this sentence? I think a word or two got dropped and I don't know what you're referring to RE "wanting it". Thanks!
4. That's kinda what I assumed Mafia do lol, regardless of Panda's alignment. We're at LYLO. Why would Mafia care about preserving KP at this point??
5. We still have almost a full day left before she would be mod-killed. I agree if that happens it's good for us, in quite a similar way to Kammm's mod-kill, as it will remove all doubt and debate whilst giving us answers and other info to work with. I would personally be very surprised if Ryumia just gets mod-killed though, she has demonstrated she is both thoughtful and thorough in her play here until her last post (where she said she needs to cool down her head iirc). Her only other activity on TBT since then was a post in the "what's bothering you" thread and the message she left for Chick that Heyden already mentioned, which fits with how seriously she seems to have been taking this game.
Based on the above, I'm anticipating she will be back. If I'm right, I look forward to seeing her role-claim and her thoughts on recent developments, as well as her reads. Ryumia if you see this, I second what Heyden said in post # 3728, I hope you will play in future Mafia games.
@Kayla: I'm just not writing him off is all. I can agree that it is a better sign that nobody defended Antonio against a lynch early on and Mog showed some antagonism towards him but that post I ran across just made me slightly uncomfortable.
@Amanda: I think if mafia keeps KP up at 2 it's still helpful, even though a mislynch is priority, because certain clears/prs (Vanessa and Ness probably) need to be gotten rid of and having 2 kills would help if mafia is taking a less forceful approach to this situation. And yeah if Panda was mafia they wouldn't want her claiming survivor unless it was panic moment they could do nothing about because that is probably a person who is vulnerable to being lynched and I figure they would more carefully approach her claiming in thread in order to not lose her. And that is why I feel more sure about her being survivor rather than maf but there's still a chance it could have been a panic moment on her part and if so, it would make me feel better about Heyden and the only loss here would be losing someone who doesn't count towards town numbers.
And what I was saying to Vanessa with that sentence was a way of me saying I'll drop the request to know who she protected last night after she responded, particularly because I don't think this is gonna be a mislynch. If it is, Panda gamethrew.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Then again I think she is gonna die tonight if we survive but I can kinda see the point in still keeping quiet about it if she can't protect the same person twice in a row, especially if the person she was on wasn't in the unclear pool anyways.
Also, in case people wanna know where I'm at with level of sus from greatest to least: Heyden > Amanda > Kayla > Antonio > Ryumia. But also if any of the pr claims are fake, great job.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually you know what? I can agree that Antonio is pretty unsus if I can shake off the Mog and Tom defense as bad nubplay. And it would be Heyden > Amanda > Kayla > Ryumia > Antonio. And if Panda flips red, I'd change that to Amanda > Kayla > Ryumia > Heyden/Antonio and feel more sure about the team.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh wait Amanda I clarified the wrong sentence. I am saying I want a Panda lynch because I disagree with Ness in that it won't be as informational, but I think it is, because in the off chance Panda flips red I wouldn't feel comfortable lynching Heyden that next day due to his reaction testing and bold sus of role flavortext.
@Amanda: I think if mafia keeps KP up at 2 it's still helpful, even though a mislynch is priority, because certain clears/prs (Vanessa and Ness probably) need to be gotten rid of and having 2 kills would help if mafia is taking a less forceful approach to this situation. And yeah if Panda was mafia they wouldn't want her claiming survivor unless it was panic moment they could do nothing about because that is probably a person who is vulnerable to being lynched and I figure they would more carefully approach her claiming in thread in order to not lose her. And that is why I feel more sure about her being survivor rather than maf but there's still a chance it could have been a panic moment on her part and if so, it would make me feel better about Heyden and the only loss here would be losing someone who doesn't count towards town numbers.
And what I was saying to Vanessa with that sentence was a way of me saying I'll drop the request to know who she protected last night after she responded, particularly because I don't think this is gonna be a mislynch. If it is, Panda gamethrew.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Then again I think she is gonna die tonight if we survive but I can kinda see the point in still keeping quiet about it if she can't protect the same person twice in a row, especially if the person she was on wasn't in the unclear pool anyways.
Also, in case people wanna know where I'm at with level of sus from greatest to least: Heyden > Amanda > Kayla > Antonio > Ryumia. But also if any of the pr claims are fake, great job.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually you know what? I can agree that Antonio is pretty unsus if I can shake off the Mog and Tom defense as bad nubplay. And it would be Heyden > Amanda > Kayla > Ryumia > Antonio. And if Panda flips red, I'd change that to Amanda > Kayla > Ryumia > Heyden/Antonio and feel more sure about the team.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh wait Amanda I clarified the wrong sentence. I am saying I want a Panda lynch because I disagree with Ness in that it won't be as informational, but I think it is, because in the off chance Panda flips red I wouldn't feel comfortable lynching Heyden that next day due to his reaction testing and bold sus of role flavortext.
