Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

tae said:
????

vvvvvv ???

Post automatically merged:

i waited to vote him until i heard his argument? but once he said "im not cop but what if sheeps lying?" i voted him bc thats stupid LOL
Click to expand...
oh
my eyes glazed over ig
 
  • Like
Reactions: tae
BetsySundrop said:
If it's random, game over, we win. If it's not, at least he won't be dragged into an f3 as an easy target. And I believe with random out, if he flips town, the nk will still net enough info for tessa in f3, especially if the nk is/is not sidney.
Click to expand...

if sidney flips green and random is in the final day at MYLO, do you think the best option would be to vote random out d4? or depending on whos nk'd who do you think the strongest argument is against in the options that will present for d4? does random surving the night = to them being mafia?


(random nk'd) betsy, tessa, tae.
(tessa nk'd) betsy, tae, random.
(tae nk'd) betsy, random, tessa.
Post automatically merged:

also idk if random's even gonna come back to vote at this point, we know he'll vote diney to save himself but if he doesn't show up at all, its a 50/50 chance for the elim.
 
tae said:
if sidney flips green and random is in the final day at MYLO, do you think the best option would be to vote random out d4? or depending on whos nk'd who do you think the strongest argument is against in the options that will present for d4? does random surving the night = to them being mafia?
Click to expand...

That's a tough question. I think if the elim today doesn't flip maf and end the game, and I end up in f3 with random/anyone, I'd probably go over everything a million times, look through every single post a few times, and then vote and still worry....

I don't like to just auto vote without thinking.

My nightmare would be an f3, voting wrong, losing the whole game. So yeah, I'd obsess over my vote....
Post automatically merged:

Also, random surviving the night could be:

Maf!random, in which nk might be me for voting him.

Town!random, in which nk might be anyone, because I believe wolf!tae or wolf!tessa could pressure random.
 
tae said:
if sidney flips green and random is in the final day at MYLO, do you think the best option would be to vote random out d4? or depending on whos nk'd who do you think the strongest argument is against in the options that will present for d4? does random surving the night = to them being mafia?


(random nk'd) betsy, tessa, tae.
(tessa nk'd) betsy, tae, random.
(tae nk'd) betsy, random, tessa.
Post automatically merged:

also idk if random's even gonna come back to vote at this point, we know he'll vote diney to save himself but if he doesn't show up at all, its a 50/50 chance for the elim.
Click to expand...
I don't think random surviving the night means they're mafia. they would be too easy a target

If random is nk'd, I think tae/betsy

tessa nk'd, i say...mmm. maybe random, actually

tae nk'd, i actually think it maybe WOULDNT be random.

The issue is that talking about it too much as well makes things more confusing after the fact
 
  • Like
Reactions: tae
BetsySundrop said:
That's a tough question. I think if the elim today doesn't flip maf and end the game, and I end up in f3 with random/anyone, I'd probably go over everything a million times, look through every single post a few times, and then vote and still worry....

I don't like to just auto vote without thinking.

My nightmare would be an f3, voting wrong, losing the whole game. So yeah, I'd obsess over my vote....
Post automatically merged:

Also, random surviving the night could be:

Maf!random, in which nk might be me for voting him.

Town!random, in which nk might be anyone, because I believe wolf!tae or wolf!tessa could pressure random.
Click to expand...

ur more certain now that random is mafia than sidney in this current place in time? or is ur argument for voting random today simply bc you dont trust them in f3?
 
day ends in 45.
are we comfortable in a 50-50 chance with a split vote.

i see the point of random being a bad f3 candidate, but also i can't bring myself to not hold true to my scumlean on sidney.
 
tae said:
ur more certain now that random is mafia than sidney in this current place in time? or is ur argument for voting random today simply bc you dont trust them in f3?
Click to expand...

I think it's possible it could be either sidney or random, and really hoping the game is finished tonight.

But viewing the overall game, I really don't think it'd be a good idea to have random in f3, especially with the level of sus I have on him. No offense to random, but if he is town, I don't see him trying to go over all of the posts and trying to figure it out.
Post automatically merged:

tae said:
day ends in 45.
are we comfortable in a 50-50 chance with a split vote.

i see the point of random being a bad f3 candidate, but also i can't bring myself to not hold true to my scumlean on sidney.
Click to expand...
I'm not 100% happy, but I can't make up my mind on which one it is, and both are possible.

And the risk of maf manipulating random is just too high, imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tae
BetsySundrop said:
But anything we can try to figure out now might help f3 if we misselim?
Click to expand...
If you eliminate me, you’re eliminating a town.

So yeah, I agree, we should try to figure out as much as possible.

At the same time, we have only 40 minutes left and a still-absent random whose the biggest wildcard in my mind right now

I don’t have any good wisdom if I end up being the vote aside from to figure out random, but don’t be too certain it’s random either ?
Post automatically merged:

BetsySundrop said:
I think it's possible it could be either sidney or random, and really hoping the game is finished tonight.

But viewing the overall game, I really don't think it'd be a good idea to have random in f3, especially with the level of sus I have on him. No offense to random, but if he is town, I don't see him trying to go over all of the posts and trying to figure it out.
Post automatically merged:


I'm not 100% happy, but I can't make up my mind on which one it is, and both are possible.

And the risk of maf manipulating random is just too high, imo.
Click to expand...
These are my thoughts as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tae
tae said:
i see the point of random being a bad f3 candidate, but also i can't bring myself to not hold true to my scumlean on sidney.
Click to expand...

I'd say hold true to your instincts if you're confident, lol. Mine are awful, seriously. And you might be right and win us the game.
 
BetsySundrop said:
I'd say hold true to your instincts if you're confident, lol. Mine are awful, seriously. And you might be right and win us the game.
Click to expand...
i mean if random dies today w/ the 50-50 rng (if random doesnt vote before eod), and i make it through the night, my biggest sus is still sidney (unless she's nk'd ofc). it just seems like a lot of passive "well its a 50-50 time to see what rng brings us" and that gives me so much anxiety right now. please nk me and put me out of my misery
 
BetsySundrop said:
I'd say hold true to your instincts if you're confident, lol. Mine are awful, seriously. And you might be right and win us the game.
Click to expand...
I disagree but know myself to be town. I say if you think you have a better chance of winning tomorrow voting me over random, go for it. and then good luck lol
Post automatically merged:

tae said:
i mean if random dies today w/ the 50-50 rng (if random doesnt vote before eod), and i make it through the night, my biggest sus is still sidney (unless she's nk'd ofc). it just seems like a lot of passive "well its a 50-50 time to see what rng brings us" and that gives me so much anxiety right now. please nk me and put me out of my misery
Click to expand...
I have no big pushes aside from random right now. I could see arguments for everyone else as just being town

i dont rlly feel confident in my final day abilities in the slightest and you've explicitly said you'll still focus on me tomorrow (and I'm legitimately just newbie town) so I'm like. accepting of my fate at this point
 
tae said:
if sidney flips green and random is in the final day at MYLO, do you think the best option would be to vote random out d4? or depending on whos nk'd who do you think the strongest argument is against in the options that will present for d4? does random surving the night = to them being mafia?


(random nk'd) betsy, tessa, tae.
(tessa nk'd) betsy, tae, random.
(tae nk'd) betsy, random, tessa.
Post automatically merged:

also idk if random's even gonna come back to vote at this point, we know he'll vote diney to save himself but if he doesn't show up at all, its a 50/50 chance for the elim.
Click to expand...
If random is nk'd i will go bat**** insane
 
  • Like
Reactions: tae
BetsySundrop said:
My nightmare would be an f3, voting wrong, losing the whole game. So yeah, I'd obsess over my vote....
Click to expand...
Your nightmare was MY REALITY. TWICE.

in all seriousness if the vote is tied i dont mind leaving it up to fate to be entirely honest. i think both random/sidney could be maf or could provide us with info, though i would rather vote sidney out.
 
but last random was last seen at 12:20pm my time.
.. they really popped in posted 3 sentences again and just left w/o voting?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
101K
unravel
unravel
N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
920
N e s s
N e s s
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
51K
Jacob4
Jacob4
TN4U
Mafia Redd's Revenge - Game Thread [GAME OVER]
56 57 58
Replies
1K
Views
31K
BetsySundrop
BetsySundrop
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
Back
Top