Mafia Salmon Run Mafia *main thread* [GAME OVER. SEE POST #460 FOR RESULTS.]

[BetsySundrop]

Right now I'm trying to avoid a stupid tunnel, so looking at everyone.

-Ghost seems really town. Usually a defensive ghost is town ghost, and that's what I was picking up from him.
-shell seems very active/solvy, so leaning town. (Only thing keeping from solid town is shell is also excellent at faking and looking the most town when maf, lol- evil genius).

I don't think activity is necessarily AI, but without activity, it's possible for maf to hide so it makes me uncomfortable. Elundor, b100, and caff I think are low activity and would like to see more to get a better read. I know b100 said she was busy with other things, and elundor and caff are new. So hope to see more today, reads and reasoning, to help make up my mind on them for town/sus.

Misty/tessa I've kind of got neutral, poss leaning town.

Shawo- a bit sus. I was questioning shawo because a couple things made me a bit uncomfortable. The initial pr reveal I hadn't seen before and thought was odd, a newbie making a mistake and probably gonna be nk. But in this kind of game, with abilities unknown (so not really likely to be a counterclaim), it could be a good way to avoid getting voted off d1 if you knew you wouldn't be nk. Then several posts seeming to push for info on other pr abilities...

I'm trying not to death tunnel, because I am forever putting my town to sus in a logically ordered list and STILL getting it wrong. So will be on later this afternoon to make a final decision for voting.

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

D2?

Yeah, the way people vote d1, including eod activity, can give more information to use in solving on d2.

 

[shellbell]

Because it’s a placeholder for whoever I think is sus. Not much going on rn. Shawo is sus, and Caffline was so willing to trust Tessa after 1 POST. (Tempted to vote Caffline because of last match)

i get that it's a placeholder, but usually you put down somebody's name and tbh using no elim as a placeholder is highly sus... like you're saying it's a placeholder for who's sus, but then you vote no elim, even though you named two people who you find sus?

also why is shawo sus to you?

i'm not questioning ghost's no elim cause it fits with him usually just voting what you vote lol

Question from a noob, why would we elim someone on day one when we have no evidence to go on? The possibility of us voting off a inkling is so much higher.

Not saying I’m not willing, just want to understand why we’re willing to sacrifice one of our own?

basically what @BetsySundrop said. taking a chance to sacrifice is still better than not taking the chance to strike at mafia. and it's not like there's going to be "evidence" anyway because it becomes a game of he said she said. it's all speculation, but the voting is public. mafia will be more likely to vote no elim because they're more fearful of being voted off than town would be.

 

[Ghost2008]

I’m not a huge noob but I am an ok noob.
Also yeah based on weapons mafia might kill

 

[shellbell]

-shell seems very active/solvy, so leaning town. (Only thing keeping from solid town is shell is also excellent at faking and looking the most town when maf, lol- evil genius).

I'm trying not to death tunnel, because I am forever putting my town to sus in a logically ordered list and STILL getting it wrong. So will be on later this afternoon to make a final decision for voting.

aww betsy you should definitely just trust your instincts. also i'm very active because i just love splatoon so much. i wanna solve all these weapons and what they do!!!

 

[Ghost2008]

aww betsy you should definitely just trust your instincts. also i'm very active because i just love splatoon so much. i wanna solve all these weapons and what they do!!!

Shell your always fun to play mafia with because you search people and don’t let them get away with being sus. Also your encouraging.

 

[shellbell]

Shell your always fun to play mafia with because you search people and don’t let them get away with being sus. Also your encouraging.

thank you, ghost

and for what it's worth i'm noticing a lot of improvement in your posts this game

 

[Ghost2008]

Hehe yeah I used to make those weird random posts but I’m getting better at the game which is a yay

 

[BetsySundrop]

aww betsy you should definitely just trust your instincts. also i'm very active because i just love splatoon so much. i wanna solve all these weapons and what they do!!!

Truting my instincts got me killed in your maf game! But my instincts are telling me you're town....again....

Lol my weapon kinda sucks, ngl. It would probably be more useful in the hands of someone else with better instincts.

 

[Ghost2008]

I have incredible instincts he said in a tone indicating he had awful instincts

 

[shellbell]

Truting my instincts got me killed in your maf game! But my instincts are telling me you're town....again....

Lol my weapon kinda sucks, ngl. It would probably be more useful in the hands of someone else with better instincts.

i wish there was a reaction so i don't have to post more fluff here lol

I have incredible instincts he said in a tone indicating he had awful instincts

 

[Ghost2008]

Did you laugh?

 

[shellbell]

Did you laugh?

yes

i'm going to sleep now. no more fluff for me

(shrek?)

 

[Ghost2008]

He’s my favorite meme

 

[b100ming]

Ghost seems really town. Usually a defensive ghost is town ghost, and that's what I was picking up from him.

He’s only been mafia once? That’s not a good reason to TR him. I’ve played countless rounds of Among Us with him, I should know.

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

@Ghost2008 You know you aren’t allowed to do shrek related memes till the end of January.

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

also why is shawo sus to you?

Didn’t shawo claim a pr? They claimed rolecop right? The cop roles are the most dangerous to claim. They didn’t seem worried from what I saw. Mafia wouldn’t because they can’t be killed by mafia, if that makes sense.

 

[tessa grace]

Because it’s a placeholder for whoever I think is sus. Not much going on rn. Shawo is sus, and Caffline was so willing to trust Tessa after 1 POST. (Tempted to vote Caffline because of last match)

Honestly I feel like the placeholder is really unnecessary.
What are your townreads? How come shawo is suspicious to you?

I definitely think b100ms play today has been a lot different than usual, and not just lack of activity. Just your overall approach on the game. I don't wanna miselim b100m by accident d1, again.... ugh this is hard.

I don't really understand the shawo sus atm. Seems to me they're just pretty confident. Plus, they wouldn't be so bold to say "oh i'm important pr" because they know thats how people are instantly suspicious of you.

Betsy is always town in my eyes, i refuse to elaborate and its frustrating to read her. STOP ALWAYS BEING TOWNLIKE BETSY

yes

i'm going to sleep now. no more fluff for me

(shrek?)

I just woke up. Looks like we won't have a lot of interaction with timezones like that

I'm not gonna read shell for a bit because I have trust issues from that one game when you were mafia... I think I'll maybe iso today or tm (assuming one of us doesn't die) but I always immediately townread you so I need to rethink things this time around.

I agree with most that I'd like to hear more from b100m caff and elundor. What do you guys think about things we've discussed? Who do you find suspicious and why?

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

Yes understood

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

Anyone wishing to ask me any questions?

Do you have questions for anyone as well?

 

[b100ming]

Alright, maybe placeholder was the wrong word, but it’s d1 and we don’t have much solid evidence.

 

[tessa grace]

Alright, maybe placeholder was the wrong word, but it’s d1 and we don’t have much solid evidence.

So it's not a placeholder? I feel like we've been in several games where most of town has agreed eliminating d1 versus not doing so is the better option. Why don't you think so as well?

 

[Ghost2008]

No question yet

 

[Caffline]

It’s so hard to read the room on day 1, especially with so many people. Last I played, day 1 only had 4 people a group so it was easier.

My town leans so far - tessa , b100ming and ghost. Tessa seems both more relaxed and eager to figure things out this time compared to last time. When she was mafia, I got the feeling that she was trying to fly under the radar but not getting that this time. b100ming calling out wolf to not reveal his ability to prevent being targeted by mafia also seems pretty town to me. Ghost giving his weapon name out so quickly makes him my most certain town read so far.

My sus group - elundor and shawo. Elundor because he volunteered to collect golden eggs so quick. Especially because he’s new, I’d assume someone who is in the dark about everything to scope things out a bit first. Shawo is the most sus to me right now, but that might be because of the very direct and to the point play style. Shawo is either a really good town leader or wolf. Like I want to know why Shawo is pushing everyone to be transparent when they’ve been pretty elusive about their own powers.

Post automatically merged: Dec 12, 2021

Who is everyone’s top choice elim? I can’t bring myself to pin anyone right now - everyone seems like a friend… but also *shifty eyes*

We need one more golden egg right? Shell, you still up for that?

 

[BetsySundrop]

He’s only been mafia once? That’s not a good reason to TR him. I’ve played countless rounds of Among Us with him, I should know.

You and ghost probably know each other the best, lol. But I do think he reads more town in his entry to the game.

I don't really understand the shawo sus atm. Seems to me they're just pretty confident. Plus, they wouldn't be so bold to say "oh i'm important pr" because they know thats how people are instantly suspicious of you.

Betsy is always town in my eyes, i refuse to elaborate and its frustrating to read her. STOP ALWAYS BEING TOWNLIKE BETSY

I am town this time.

For shawo- yeah, I dunno. I mentioned his early posts. Felt like he was pressing for info early on in the game that could lead to pr nks. D1 is always a pain.

We need one more golden egg right? Shell, you still up for that?

I'll be back on in a bit (gotta cook) -might be more posts from people, hopefully to help decide.

And yes- we need 1 more egg! There's just a couple hours left.