• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Salmon Run Mafia *main thread* [GAME OVER. SEE POST #460 FOR RESULTS.]

It’s so hard to read the room on day 1, especially with so many people. Last I played, day 1 only had 4 people a group so it was easier.

My town leans so far - tessa , b100ming and ghost. Tessa seems both more relaxed and eager to figure things out this time compared to last time. When she was mafia, I got the feeling that she was trying to fly under the radar but not getting that this time. b100ming calling out wolf to not reveal his ability to prevent being targeted by mafia also seems pretty town to me. Ghost giving his weapon name out so quickly makes him my most certain town read so far.

My sus group - elundor and shawo. Elundor because he volunteered to collect golden eggs so quick. Especially because he’s new, I’d assume someone who is in the dark about everything to scope things out a bit first. Shawo is the most sus to me right now, but that might be because of the very direct and to the point play style. Shawo is either a really good town leader or wolf. Like I want to know why Shawo is pushing everyone to be transparent when they’ve been pretty elusive about their own powers.
Post automatically merged:

Who is everyone’s top choice elim? I can’t bring myself to pin anyone right now - everyone seems like a friend… but also *shifty eyes*

We need one more golden egg right? Shell, you still up for that?

Look, I asserted why I went for an egg! I wasn't sure how this game flowed... figured the best impact i could have was to just grab an egg! I'm fairly busy with work during the day, but that's the input I have for now. Shawo is still sus to me, something feels off with them.
 
I do not like the unsureness of b100ming talking about her weapon/pr thingy. It felt almost subtle enough to reassure us that she's town without giving away too much and being called out for faking an ability.
So for bloom: If you're not sure the power of your ability, will you collect golden eggs?
@b100ming I'm going to reiterate this question. You answered my other questions so I'm not sure why you avoided this? But I would love an answer because you not answering felt more suspicious.
Post automatically merged:

Look, I asserted why I went for an egg! I wasn't sure how this game flowed... figured the best impact i could have was to just grab an egg! I'm fairly busy with work during the day, but that's the input I have for now. Shawo is still sus to me, something feels off with them.
Honestly I think this is pretty valid, I pretty much did the same thing (got an egg first post with a short explanation)
 
Sorry for being so inactive today. Sundays are busy days in my family. Have to say I'm liking the 7pm EoD because it means I don't need to mess around with being on mobile midday and I can take my time catching up and getting some interactions in. Speaking of which, catching up now.
 
To me it felt more like an observation versus an accusation. I'm not necessarily townreading blooming, but I think she was just trying to point something out for town. It did feel like something that at we could've assumed, though. (at least i considered it at the start of game)
But what does it do for town other than make us more paranoid of each other and therefore less likely to find each other as town? That's my issue with it, and why I asked if she brought it up because she was sus of Ghost specifically, because I want to understand where the theory came from. As soon as people started TRing Ghost she dropped the discussion point (course she could have also been busy but my question still went unanswered).

I don't really understand the shawo sus atm. Seems to me they're just pretty confident. Plus, they wouldn't be so bold to say "oh i'm important pr" because they know thats how people are instantly suspicious of you.
Everyone is a PR in this game. Unless they're specifically trying to bait a night kill, I just don't understand the strategy of saying that their ability is so OP that they believe it's worth others not using their own abilities every night because they said they refuse to collect eggs.

Didn’t shawo claim a pr? They claimed rolecop right? The cop roles are the most dangerous to claim. They didn’t seem worried from what I saw. Mafia wouldn’t because they can’t be killed by mafia, if that makes sense.
No. We were discussing rolecops, but I don't think they specifically claimed it. And like I said above, everyone is a PR so I'm not sure why one person's vague claim is being put on a higher pedestal than everyone else's vague claims.
 
Yeah I know. That's why I'm refreshing the Cellar page occasionally to keep an eye both on this thread and the day action thread.

But what about you? Any thoughts going into EoD?

Yeah im thinking about a few to vote from, incl elundor and shawo.
I know elundor is new, but iso is very few posts and just sus one person (shawo) on feeling. I get it, I did question/sus shawo myself. But i dunno, seems a bit, empty but focused on one person?
Post automatically merged:

I hope the quiet is not people avoiding egg collecting... (and I feel really bad for even saying that)...
 
Last edited:
Currently the vote is set at NO ELIM and only 4 of 5 golden eggs have been collected. EoD is in 20 minutes.
Post automatically merged:

You can vote and / or collect golden eggs in the Day Action Thread
 
Yeah im thinking about a few to vote from, incl elundor and shawo.
I know elundor is new, but iso is very few posts and just sus one person (shawo) on feeling. I get it, I did question/sus shawo myself. But i dunno, seems a bit, empty but focused on one person?
Post automatically merged:

I hope the quiet is not people avoiding egg collecting... (and I feel really bad for even saying that)...
I can agree with your thoughts on Elundor, especially because a fair number of people have walked through their reasoning for suspecting Shawo in particular and Elundor is still leaving it cagey and vague. OTOH though, iirc Elundor was one of the first to point out that they sussed Shawo, rather than it being a reaction to everyone else's explanations. I dunno, if Shawo is town the salmonids probably do want to get them out of the game over the hinted power of their role, so I can see trying to lead a miselim there, but Elundor's post doesn't really seem leading. Despite being one of the first, it feels like a lot of people found Shawo sus independently rather than using that post to guide their thoughts there. I can agree that it does seem weirdly focused on Shawo despite the fact that quite a few of us have just as much, if not more, posts than Shawo atm. (But there's also this sappy part of me that I know is going to get me into trouble because I can already feel myself being more willing to give the benefit of the doubt to people who've literally taken one for the team by collecting eggs and I'm sitting here like 'shawo stuff aside, they collected an egg and their reasoning for it seemed pure in a n00b-y way so maybe town 🥺' My soft side needs to die lol)
 
I'm with Tessa, leaning towards voting b100m after today's discussions. Shawo is sus to me due to secondhand information about them being a veteran player but suddenly claiming to be new?
 
I'm with Tessa, leaning towards voting b100m after today's discussions. Shawo is sus to me due to secondhand information about them being a veteran player but suddenly claiming to be new?
I think my biggest issue is that she ignored my stuff about the golden eggs and answered everything else. Felt like an easy way to sabatoge town
 
@Miss Misty if it comes down to the two of us, how much do you think you having your ability helps night 1? Mine is maybe a 5 so if you’re higher, I’ll get the egg.
 
@Miss Misty if it comes down to the two of us, how much do you think you having your ability helps night 1? Mine is maybe a 5 so if you’re higher, I’ll get the egg.
Like I said my ability is very situational. It could be very helpful, or it could be a complete dud. Depends on how other things shake out. Like it's more beneficial the earlier I start using it, but not at the risk of town losing.
Post automatically merged:

And I realize that's probably not what you want to hear since it works out to be about a 5 as well so I guess I'll just go collect because I want to get it over with, and I'll just hope the rest of y'all can do good with your stuff.
 
not me scrambling awake for eod @_@

I'm voting b100ming and i'll get an egg. i'm also not feeling good with all this sus on shawo, particularly eyeing the people who expressed it.
and @shawo where's the push today that you promised?
 
Back
Top