Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
in that case, they'd be aligned with the hostiles if their motive was to confuse town.
what’s
what question
oath2order
#Porygon2024
I make two posts pointing fingers and y'all ignore them smh
maybe they just wanna mess around n have some fun as SK
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
maybe they just wanna mess around n have some fun as SK
i don’t think SKs always leave notes.
they do in ToS but in order for a message to be seen is have to be dead so idk what you’re talking about.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
It's interesting that Punchy is accusing another player of pocketing, because that's what I think he was attempting to do earlier with mog, townlocking her day one. He then, in post 592, moves mog down to a townread as opposed to Townlock, presumably to not look suspicious for a townlock on day one but still wanting to pocket.
she's literally REEKING town, i said there was a few posts that gave me slight pause so i moved her down
I don't know why but this post just reeks to me.
i don't think we should talk about pr claims in general, i didnt want him to out his partner by giving an obvious hint as to who they were and he ended up being real also
Like, if you think he's town, then why would you want him to be dead? Unless if you're scum.
i just said i didn't believe he was town there
You know, this is weird too. You critique Locket on day 1 for having vague reads. (I then also kind of agree with you but also say the same thing. But looking back, your reads on day 1 weren't all that detailed either. How could you critique someone from having vague reads when having vague ones yourself?
that isn't the same thing. my reads had some reasoning behind them and iirc i dont remember her giving reasoning at all
Continuing to pocket.
I said that because it is ****ing TRUE oath and now that mog is semi-confirmed it makes me right. tbh i thought mog was a pr from her posts, i just didn't want to out that for obvious reasons
I think a lot of your reads are crap. You're continuing on the Mog pocket, you clear evan because his "tone felt natural"? What sort of read is that? You nullread glow because of something you hear? Maybe make an analysis?
where did i clear him? i townread him lmao. glow has been ehh the whole game and i was waiting for her to start trying to leadbut she hasn't so i'm going to iso her soon. tbh i was hoping she'd die at night so i didn't have to read a strong player.
You say that tae is not aligned with f11. But you scumlean both of them. How can you logically scumlean both of them. Do you believe f11 now, and do you think tae is still not aligned with f11?
they're individually scummy, but they aren't scum together. if one flips maf, the other is town.
At this point in the game, I had felt Heyden was making some good attempts, I don't see how you can scumlean them for not memeing.
i definitely didn't think that they were doing that? they were relatively lowposting and i think they would meme in past games while still trying to lead but I don't remember a single readslist
What's interesting is that in here you say you thought Geoni was slightly scummy early on, and then slowly throughout day 2 you townlock him.
never townlocked him, in the past few games i've played with him he has pushed agendas in nearly every post, this game i felt a pure essence radiating out of the posts.
I think it's suspicious that in post 2014, you post this reads again. You keep the words "I honestly believe this person is mafia" for Panda in both posts, but move Panda from Wolfread to the lesser Wolflean. Why? Is it to make yourself look less suspicious when your team presumably killed her on Night 2?
i thought Antonio was masons with her. I laid off of her temporarily. I also thought Antonio and f11 had progressed to a more wolfy state then panda tbh
most of his reads on me are interactions with flipped town
this case also feels nitpicky too. might iso oath later
she's literally REEKING town, i said there was a few posts that gave me slight pause so i moved her down
I don't know why but this post just reeks to me.
i don't think we should talk about pr claims in general, i didnt want him to out his partner by giving an obvious hint as to who they were and he ended up being real also
Like, if you think he's town, then why would you want him to be dead? Unless if you're scum.
i just said i didn't believe he was town there
You know, this is weird too. You critique Locket on day 1 for having vague reads. (I then also kind of agree with you but also say the same thing. But looking back, your reads on day 1 weren't all that detailed either. How could you critique someone from having vague reads when having vague ones yourself?
that isn't the same thing. my reads had some reasoning behind them and iirc i dont remember her giving reasoning at all
Continuing to pocket.
I said that because it is ****ing TRUE oath and now that mog is semi-confirmed it makes me right. tbh i thought mog was a pr from her posts, i just didn't want to out that for obvious reasons
I think a lot of your reads are crap. You're continuing on the Mog pocket, you clear evan because his "tone felt natural"? What sort of read is that? You nullread glow because of something you hear? Maybe make an analysis?
where did i clear him? i townread him lmao. glow has been ehh the whole game and i was waiting for her to start trying to leadbut she hasn't so i'm going to iso her soon. tbh i was hoping she'd die at night so i didn't have to read a strong player.
You say that tae is not aligned with f11. But you scumlean both of them. How can you logically scumlean both of them. Do you believe f11 now, and do you think tae is still not aligned with f11?
they're individually scummy, but they aren't scum together. if one flips maf, the other is town.
At this point in the game, I had felt Heyden was making some good attempts, I don't see how you can scumlean them for not memeing.
i definitely didn't think that they were doing that? they were relatively lowposting and i think they would meme in past games while still trying to lead but I don't remember a single readslist
What's interesting is that in here you say you thought Geoni was slightly scummy early on, and then slowly throughout day 2 you townlock him.
never townlocked him, in the past few games i've played with him he has pushed agendas in nearly every post, this game i felt a pure essence radiating out of the posts.
I think it's suspicious that in post 2014, you post this reads again. You keep the words "I honestly believe this person is mafia" for Panda in both posts, but move Panda from Wolfread to the lesser Wolflean. Why? Is it to make yourself look less suspicious when your team presumably killed her on Night 2?
i thought Antonio was masons with her. I laid off of her temporarily. I also thought Antonio and f11 had progressed to a more wolfy state then panda tbh
most of his reads on me are interactions with flipped town
this case also feels nitpicky too. might iso oath later
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Wow, punchy actually wrote a well written post for once.
I haven't seen this much wall posting all game, is your internet working now?
I haven't seen this much wall posting all game, is your internet working now?
Post automatically merged:
CAN YOU NOT CURSE FOR LIKE TEN MINUTES
if that's the case then this game is way too experimental.maybe they just wanna mess around n have some fun as SK
also oh my goodness punchy i'm proud of you for the long post.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
oh boy wait until he sees that i'm just replying and i didn't write all of that lol
power was back up when i started talking about my power being out and me being on mobile
didn't want to make excuses but you were being an ass so
Post automatically merged:
guys that was literally just 10 one liners lmao
bold is oath
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
I'm just pointing out your hypocrisy, carry on.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
No no no you lie! You did NOT think that Antonio was mason with her, you specifically had said at numerous points that you did not think he was mason at all.
You thought Panda was his partner.
You said as recently as Friday that you thought Antonio's claim was false. You're trying to retcon the fact that you very recently thought you thought Antonio was lying.
And of course now that I have a post against you, you decide it's time to ISO me. Because of course.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Still though, it's quite alot even if you ignore the bold.
And since the power is back on, I hope we see more of you.
@oath2order punchy did think panda was his mando bc he outed her before i did. i only outed my purple skin comment i saw from antonio thinking panda was his manson based off that AFTER punchy pointed it out in thread.
Post automatically merged:
why protect him? you think he’s actually town?
What if I want to protect myself uwu
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Because if you use it on shawo, he can copy you and we will have 2 bus drivers on our side unless you are voted off during night.
Post automatically merged:
He claimed absorber, didn't you hear?
Post automatically merged:
I already implied that upside texts were lies and I was baiting mafia that the person was inactive.
- Status
