i'm extremely apologetic for this whole wall post, but it seems like 99.8% of the discussion happens when i'm asleep. ;(
Emolga59 - There isn't much to go off here, but RQS answers give me very slight town vibes.
is this meant to be a gut read, because there's nothing about emolga's rqs that really has anything ai.
don’t like this overthinking tbh (reference to trundle)
tbh i might just be overestimating my mog reading skills
it seems to me that you've contradicted yourself here?
most of the reads i'm seeing right now are meta-based but i don't trust the accuracy within them, as some players have mentioned that they haven't even played in a while. i'm starting to deduce that this a popular way of reading people in these forums?
punchy, you seem to be focused on players that you're familiar with (especially mog), but i'd like to know your thoughts on others too.
i think i liked shawo
their entrance reminded me of me when i first started
everybody's meta and playstyle is not the same. shawo may be playing similarly to you when you started, but they may be taking a different approach, as they could possibly be any role that we're not aware of at the moment.
it is p clear that shawo is an experienced player but ok
not necessarily, they're still yet to answer the rqs so i wouldn't have known, but i'm not going to jump on that yet.
this is townlock for day one
the words 'townlock' and 'day one' don't go together well, unless there was a slip (in which there isn't so far). punchy's playstyle may be like this, but i'd love for his thoughts on people besides mog and shawo.
Their (f11's) first post was a joke post about me vs. you and you’re the scum.
it wasn't actually a joke post, as f11 explained. it was said to be an actual read because they were sus of how jacob called an interaction 'town vs town', leading people to think that he is town because of the read he gave himself.
I'm loving the newbies this game lmao
enjoy it while it lasts.
Harbour's RQ responses felt very forced and uncertain, I know its very little to go off of but it really reads awkwardly to me.
yes, i was and still sort of am still uncertain as i'm adapting to the different play-style and people here.
I've seen it before where you need to rhyme every line in a way or you get modkilled.
i 100% don't believe that punchy has a post filter that pertains to his role. yes, he does type in distinct lines but other than that, the pattern is inconsistent and i wouldn't see why he wouldn't be able to tell us if he a had a post filter? highly doubt that this game is experimental.
my random thoughts as i was reading the thread:
- dino is a learning player so i have no read for her now. however, i feel like a player influenced by mafia teammates would probably want to act more intellectual instead of faking the newbie act.
- i agree with mog when she states that there is no connection between her and trundle. if one flips a specific role, i can't really see that being linked to the other person. it was just a reaction test, not anything that could potentially connect their roles in my opinion.
- i'm null on trundle; part of me thinks he's town because his overthinking seems kind of normal. he's been called out for it and he keeps on doing it, making me think that it's just something he naturally does? i would believe that a mafia would stop doing what they're sussed for so they could get higher up others' reads list. another part of me is just confused by his behaviour and wording (the article stuff is really perplexing to me), i can't really say any more than that.
- sheabae has been learning which i understand, and the only substantial post they've made is their rqs, which have been dry. would like to hear more from them too.
- i need to hear more from shawo too. i sus them the most so far.
