I used to watch anime constantly when I was younger, don't know why I got out of it, I've very slowly been working through Ouran High School Host Club and some of the newer Pokemon seasons, but other than that, I have no real idea where to start with getting back into anime. Anyone have any recommendations of either newer stuff that's really good, or else older classics that get overlooked? (So not something like Sailor Moon that is a classic but most people have already checked it out) I don't have any super-specific genres I'm into, although I do like sporty stuff just because watching people do sports encourages me to go and work out, I also pretty much grew up on 2000s shoujo stuff like Shugo Chara and Tokyo Mew Mew. I also like any stuff that has good LGBT representation. And then I also am totally into mysterious and dark stuff, like horror, mystery, thriller, etc. Basically... I have really broad interests, pretty much anything with a nice animation style and an intriguing story is something I can get into, no matter what genre it is.
I’m not sure you would care for anything I recommend, but I WILL go ahead and recommend My Hero Academia to you. It has sporty stuff, super heroes, AND a high school setting for most of it. I’m only on around Episode 17 of the series, season two in CrunchyRoll, but the subtitles for Animes are well-done I found out, and every episode is literally a thriller till the end.
I would warn you though that around episode 9 and up in the first season (don’t remember where), at one point there is some blood, but it’s not a lot, and nothing truly bad happens in season one.