The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Raz]

You want Murphy too, then?

Okay, you get Bill and Murphy

To be honest: I didn't like his beady eyes at first, but he is a sassy crank. Not half bad. He and Sherb get along quite well. Cute little dynamic.

I don't know why, but he kinda looks like a lazy villager haha. If you haven't told me he's a cranky, I would never guess.

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

You want Murphy too, then?

Okay, you get Bill and Murphy

To be honest: I didn't like his beady eyes at first, but he is a sassy crank. Not half bad. He and Sherb get along quite well. Cute little dynamic.

Ok, I JUST saw that and I can't help but to think of an animal crossing game with Bill Murphy in it hahaha

 

[solace]

Here are my villagers:

Spoiler: My Villagers

View attachment 252075

My personal ranking would be:
1. Peanut
2. Fauna
3. Marina
4. Chevre
5. Diana
6. Sherb
7. Flora
8. Cherry
9. Francine
10. Merengue

Curious what others think!

In NL Peanut, Fauna and Diana lived together in one of my towns! Great villagers. I can rank this one fair and square since I have played with all these villagers at one point.

Here goes:
1. Fauna
2. Sherb
3. Peanut
4. Diana
5. Francine
6. Merengue
7. Marina
8. Chevre
9. flora
10. Cherry

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

I don't know why, but he kinda looks like a lazy villager haha. If you haven't told me he's a cranky, I would never guess.

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

Ok, I JUST saw that and I can't help but to think of an animal crossing game with Bill Murphy in it hahaha

Amazing that you put that together. Mad word play skills

I think his color scheme gives off the aura lazy. Murphy has a mouth on him, that's for sure!

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

Oh yeah Bill Murray....

 

[Xara]

Here are my villagers:

Spoiler: My Villagers

View attachment 252075

My personal ranking would be:
1. Peanut
2. Fauna
3. Marina
4. Chevre
5. Diana
6. Sherb
7. Flora
8. Cherry
9. Francine
10. Merengue

Curious what others think!

10. francine
9. flora
8. peanut
7. cherry
6. merengue
5. sherb
4. chèvre
3. marina
2. fauna
1. diana

you have such good villagers!

 

[Climbintospace]

Ugh I am at the point where I am really happy with my villagers so I am having a hard time actually ranking them but here it goes:

1. Pietro
2. Marshal
3. Marina
4. Bunnie
5. Zucker
6. Stitches
7. Octavian
8. Judy
9. Rudy
10. Molly (only bc she is the newest and I couldn’t bond with her properly yet)

In my head it’s actually more like:
1. Pietro
2. Marshal
3. Everyone else

 

[Xara]

Ugh I am at the point where I am really happy with my villagers so I am having a hard time actually ranking them but here it goes:

1. Pietro
2. Marshal
3. Marina
4. Bunnie
5. Zucker
6. Stitches
7. Octavian
8. Judy
9. Rudy
10. Molly (only bc she is the newest and I couldn’t bond with her properly yet)

In my head it’s actually more like:
1. Pietro
2. Marshal
3. Everyone else

10. pietro
9. judy
8. bunnie
7. octavian
6. stitches
5. molly
4. marina
3. marshal
2. marina
1. rudy

 

[Underneath The Stars]

kinda hesitating posting here at first because my fav villagers aren't really everyone's popular dreamies i feel like, they're just my preferred or sentimental to me so i might take it personally lol but yeah like OP said, everyone has their own opinions

so rank them <333

 

[magicaldonkey2]

kinda hesitating posting here at first because my fav villagers aren't really everyone's popular dreamies i feel like, they're just my preferred or sentimental to me so i might take it personally lol but yeah like OP said, everyone has their own opinions

so rank them <333

10. shari
9. apple
8. lyman
7. maple
6. fauna
5. marina
4. jeremiah
3 marshal
2. punchy
1. tom

 

[Rowlet28]

 

[Xara]

kinda hesitating posting here at first because my fav villagers aren't really everyone's popular dreamies i feel like, they're just my preferred or sentimental to me so i might take it personally lol but yeah like OP said, everyone has their own opinions

so rank them <333

your villagers are cuties!

10. shari
9. apple
8. jeremiah
7. tom
6. maple
5. lyman
4. punchy
3. marshal
2. marina
1. fauna

 

[Dormire]

I'm curious what the majority thinks of my cuties.

It's Jacques, Mitzi, Raymond, Cheri, Diana, Merengue, Fang, Snake, Marshal and Cherry.

Personal ranking would be:
1.Mitzi
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Jacques
5. Merengue
6. Snake
7. Cherry
8. Cheri
9. Fang
10. Diana

 

[Xara]

I'm curious what the majority thinks of my cuties.

It's Jacques, Mitzi, Raymond, Cheri, Diana, Merengue, Fang, Snake, Marshal and Cherry.

10. snake
9. jacques
8. raymond
7. mitzi
6. merengue
5. cherry
4. fang
3. marshal
2. cheri
1. diana

 

[brockbrock]

kinda hesitating posting here at first because my fav villagers aren't really everyone's popular dreamies i feel like, they're just my preferred or sentimental to me so i might take it personally lol but yeah like OP said, everyone has their own opinions

so rank them <333

1. Punchy (ofc)
2. Fauna
3. Maple
4. Marina
5. Lyman
6. Marshal
7. Tom
8. Jeremiah
9. Apple
10. Shari

 

[Xara]

View attachment 252223

10. freckles
9. dom
8. raymond
7. judy
6. merengue
5. lucky
4. cube
3. sherb
2. marshal
1. dobie

 

[Rowlet28]

10. freckles
9. dom
8. raymond
7. judy
6. merengue
5. lucky
4. cube
3. sherb
2. marshal
1. dobie

Dobie is my favorite Cranky so I don't mind. Sherb is my favorite out of the new villagers.

 

[Underneath The Stars]

10. shari
9. apple
8. lyman
7. maple
6. fauna
5. marina
4. jeremiah
3 marshal
2. punchy
1. tom

your villagers are cuties!

10. shari
9. apple
8. jeremiah
7. tom
6. maple
5. lyman
4. punchy
3. marshal
2. marina
1. fauna

1. Punchy (ofc)
2. Fauna
3. Maple
4. Marina
5. Lyman
6. Marshal
7. Tom
8. Jeremiah
9. Apple
10. Shari

this thread actually helpful if you couldn't decide who to let go, in replacement of another dreamie lol
the way shari is #10 if i had to rank as well i wish there were more uchi options....

 

[Xara]

View attachment 252045

10. kyle
9. shep
8. roscoe
7. elvis
6. maple
5. punchy
4. dizzy
3. fang
2. freya
1. audie

 

[magicaldonkey2]

this thread actually helpful if you couldn't decide who to let go, in replacement of another dreamie lol
the way shari is #10 if i had to rank as well i wish there were more uchi options....

whispers: hazel or cherry would probably be the coolest uchi villahers imo-

 

[Xara]

These are my villagers residing on my second island. This should be interesting because like I said it's my second island and I just let things happen. Also, the tenth villager is Whitney I found while randomly island hopping. View attachment 252063

10. mott
9. bill
8. colton
7. melba
6. wade
5. whitney
4. sherb
3. julia
2. murphy
1. lolly

 

[Lethalia]

This is personally my dream 10 villagers for now and I love them all.

Sherb, Reneigh, Raymond, Audie, Judy, Roald, Aurora, Wolfgang, Blanche, Apollo

View attachment 251907

10. Judy
9. Raymond
8. Sherb
7. Reneigh
6. Aurora
5. Roald
4. Audie
3. Blanche
2. Apollo
1. Wolfgang

View attachment 251948View attachment 251950View attachment 251951View attachment 251959View attachment 251952
View attachment 251953View attachment 251954View attachment 251955View attachment 251956View attachment 251960
Apollo, Colton, Diana, Kiki, Lionel, Lyman, Patty, Rodeo, Shari, and Wade.

10. Colton
9. Shari
8. Patty
7. Wade
6. Lionel
5. Kiki
4. Lyman
3. Diana
2. Rodeo
1. Apollo

 

[Xara]

View attachment 252064

10. soleil
9. alfonso
8. camofrog
7. megan
6. phoebe
5. antonio
4. marcie
3. fang
2. marina
1. felicity