The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[peachycrossing9]

Here my current villagers:

Here's my personal ranking of them:

1. Alfonso
2. Rosie
3. Gayle
4. Maple
5. Diana
6. Butch
7. Ruby
8. Zucker
9. Bubbles
10. Jakey

Most of them are dreamies I wanted! Interested to see if anyone ranks them

Post automatically merged: May 3, 2020

I'm curious what the majority thinks of my cuties.

It's Jacques, Mitzi, Raymond, Cheri, Diana, Merengue, Fang, Snake, Marshal and Cherry.

Personal ranking would be:
1.Mitzi
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Jacques
5. Merengue
6. Snake
7. Cherry
8. Cheri
9. Fang
10. Diana

Oof, you have some cuties! Here's my ranking:

1. Diana
2. Fang
3. Mitzi
4. Marshal
5. Merengue
6. Raymond
7. Cheri
8. Cherry
9. Jacques
10. Snake

 

[wolfie1]

View attachment 252223

1. Cube
2. Merengue
3. Marshal
4. Raymond
5. Sherb
6. Dom
7. Judy
8. Freckles
9. Dobie
10. Lucky

 

[peachycrossing9]

kinda hesitating posting here at first because my fav villagers aren't really everyone's popular dreamies i feel like, they're just my preferred or sentimental to me so i might take it personally lol but yeah like OP said, everyone has their own opinions

so rank them <333

You have quite a few cuties! My personal ranking:

1. Fauna
2. Punchy
3. Maple
4. Marshal
5. Marina
6. Tom
7. Jeremiah
8. Apple
9. Shari
10. Lyman

 

[wolfie1]

Here my current villagers:

View attachment 252261

1. Alfonso
2. Butch
3. Gayle
4. Rosie
5. Maple
6. Zucker
7. Jakey
8. Bubbles
9. Diana
10. Ruby

1-5 were pretty difficult to rank, I love them all lol.

 

[peachycrossing9]

1. Alfonso
2. Butch
3. Gayle
4. Rosie
5. Maple
6. Zucker
7. Jakey
8. Bubbles
9. Diana
10. Ruby

1-5 were pretty difficult to rank, I love them all lol.

Omg, good to see another fellow Alfonso stan! He's the best baby :3

 

[wolfie1]

Omg, good to see another fellow Alfonso stan! He's the best baby :3

I haven't personally had him in my island but my SO had him back in New Leaf and he was so sweet!
EDIT: Called Alfonso "it" lmao. Poor baby.

 

[peachycrossing9]

I haven't personally had it in my island but my SO had him back in New Leaf and he was so sweet!

He's such a sweetheart, I'm obsessed with him xD I have his amiibo so I make sure to always have him in my towns/island.

 

[Madrox6]

These are my villagers! I'm really content with all of them for now, but I wonder how others would rank them

 

[wolfie1]

These are my villagers! I'm really content with all of them for now, but I wonder how others would rank them

View attachment 252265

1. Fang
2. Pierce
3. Merengue
4. Raymond
5. Ketchup
6. Marina
7. Tipper
8. Phoebe
9. Kidd
10. Lucky

If Tipper didn't have those eyes, I'd rank her higher, but I just can't stand them lol.

 

[Verecund]

Here my current villagers:

1. Alfonso
2. Rosie
3. Gayle
4. Maple
5. Diana
6. Butch
7. Ruby
8. Zucker
9. Bubbles
10. Jakey

1. Ruby
2. Rosie
3. Diana
4. Gayle
5. Jakey
6. Maple
7. Alfonso
8. Butch
9. Bubbles
10. Zucker

These are my villagers! I'm really content with all of them for now, but I wonder how others would rank them

1. Fang
2. Pierce
3. Raymond
4. Merengue
5. Ketchup
6. Phoebe
7. Kidd
8. Marina
9. Lucky
10. Tipper


Here are my villagers, in no particular order:

Diva
Cobb
Apple
Nate
Ava
Chadder
Nibbles
Judy
Goldie
Bruce

 

[Bwazey]

Gosh this is a tough one!

1. Flora
2. Chief
3. Ankha
4. Maple
5. Pietro
6.Cherry
7. Beau
8. Avery
9. Walker
10. Audie

I love all my villagers very much and I hate to put Audie last. I like to think they’re all externally close together in terms of favorites.

 

[Lethalia]

View attachment 252019
here is mine! molly might be replaced by coco later on...

View attachment 252019
here is mine! molly might be replaced by coco later on...

10. Lucky
9. Raymond
8. Muffy
7. Molly
6. Sherb
5. Ketchup
4. Audie
3. Marshal
2. Whitney
1. Fang

View attachment 252036

10. Zucker
9. Deirdre
8. Raymond
7. Fauna
6. Francine
5. Sprocket
4. Lolly
3. Bunnie
2. Kabuki
1. Kitty

Post automatically merged: May 4, 2020

View attachment 252045

WOW, you have such cute villagers. This is the hardest time I had ranking a list, since there isn't one I actually dislike.

10. Dizzy
9. Freya
8. Kyle
7. Audie
6. Elvis
5. Shep
4. Maple
3. Roscoe
2. Punchy
1. Fang

These are my villagers residing on my second island. This should be interesting because like I said it's my second island and I just let things happen. Also, the tenth villager is Whitney I found while randomly island hopping. View attachment 252063

9. Sherb
8. Colton
7. Julia
6. Bill
5. Wade
4. Lolly
3. Melba
2. Murphy
1. Mott

View attachment 252064

10. Marcie
9. Megan
8. Soleil
7. Marina
6. Alfonso
5. Antonio
4. Camofrog
3. Felicity
2. Phoebe
1. Fang

Here are my villagers:

Spoiler: My Villagers

View attachment 252075

My personal ranking would be:
1. Peanut
2. Fauna
3. Marina
4. Chevre
5. Diana
6. Sherb
7. Flora
8. Cherry
9. Francine
10. Merengue

Curious what others think!

10. Francine
9. Chevre
8. Marina
7. Fauna
6. Sherb
5. Peanut
4. Cherry
3. Merengue
2. Diana
1. Flora

 

[Dustbird]

Here are mine, all dreamies though I'm considering swapping Bunnie for Wolfgang:

1. Erik
2. Fauna
3. Dobie
4. Kyle
5. Deirdre
6. Audie
7. Whitney
8. Ribbot
9. Molly
10. Bunnie

I'm really curious to see how others would rate them!

 

[JKDOS]

(Ordered by move-in date)

1. Al
2. Ankha
3. Lolly
4. Mitzi
5. Punchy
6. Graham
7. Bianca
8. Wolfgang
9. Tybalt (Incoming)
10. Pashmina (Incoming)

 

[xxxxnatalie]

 

[Kirara]

Hi! Here is my current villagers, I think too much lazy and smug..any suggestions for the 10th?

 

[Meelie]

Here’s my list! Curious to see what others think of my villagers ~~
10. Savannah
9. Monty
8. Bubbles
7. O’Hare
6. Shari
5. Camofrog
4. Marina
3. Erik
2. Teddy
1. Cheri

 

[skogkyst]

For me, this is what I have so far:

10. Agent S - She's not bad, but she's not my favorite. I just don't like the peppy dialogue a lot. Her design isn't something I like a lot.
09. Mira - I like Mira quite a bit, but unfortunately I haven't gotten to know her really well. She just moved in this weekend.
08. Marina - Marina is sweet but she's a bit bland. She doesn't bring a lot to my island that Fauna and Zucker both can't cover.
07. Octavian - He's a fun addition to my island, but he's not permanent. I like him quite a bit.
06. Huck - Huck is my favorite little frog! I love his house and design, I lucked out on my Smug campsite villager.
05. Bill - Bill is great. As one of my starters, I feel a certain connection to him. I wish he would give me his picture already, though!
04. Zucker - He's super childish, but I love Zucker.
03. Blanche - She's nice and proper, has an amazing house and design, and always wears the ugly shirts I give her.
02. Bruce - Consider this a tie with #1.
01. Fauna - The nicest deer I've ever met She's really one of the most pleasant villagers on the island

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

Hi! Here is my current villagers, I think too much lazy and smug..any suggestions for the 10th?

9. beau
8.julian
7. judy
6. stitches
5. raymond
4. marshal
3. apollo
2. bob
1. audie

very basic

Post automatically merged: May 4, 2020

View attachment 252863

10. annalisa
9. reneigh
8. hans
7. wendy
6. bam
5. sherb
4. dobie
3. ankha
2. drago
1. mitzi

 

[SinnerTheCat]

10. I
9. can't
8. rank
7. my
6. villagers
5. I
4. love
3. them
2. all
1. Tom