Personally, overall, I love it here. It's not perfect but I still enjoy being here.
Many paragraphs incoming..
The Bell Tree Forums is not perfect but it's a billion times better than any main social media site. All I get for going on a place like Facebook is nothing but infinite ads, straight up hatred, AI slop, and occasional exposure to family drama
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3c0f6/3c0f6b8844b9a2f6f171cca88d0b8f5b9f4bd037" alt="Skull :skull: 💀"
This place is a breath of fresh air compared to those kinds of sites.
I didn't even know there were ads on here for the longest time because of the way they are placed
I do think a stronger, clearer stance against racism/sexism/transphobia/homophobia/alt-right views should be taken. To be fair, I personally haven't seen a bunch of this directly on TBT (not saying it doesn't exist, I believe those who say it does), but I did report something really horrible almost a year ago, and it was taken very seriously by the staff. I really, really don't want to see that kind of crowd accumulate in this community. I don't think the staff does either. Hatred has no place here (and no matter what the alt-right says, hatred
does not equal freedom of speech/expression, especially on a privately run Animal Crossing fan site lmao). Those kinds of views should not be tolerated here in the slightest, as hatred is becoming more and more acceptable in the current political climate.. TBT should be a safe space.
Additionally, I think it's worth considering completely banning twitter links on here. Bluesky exists now and isn't run by someone who is a genuine nazi as far as I know, so...
I remember a staff member saying that a ban on politics was being considered but I don't know if that's the right course of action anymore, as pretty much everything gets politicized these days.
I absolutely hate AI generated imagery (I don't want to call it art because it is not and never will be). It's so ugly, utterly lazy, boring, and downright problematic. I think it's great that staff don't allow for it to be entered in art events/contests. I think they should consider banning AI generated imagery being used as references as well, if possible. With all that said, I wonder how realistic it would be for them to ban AI images being used as profile pictures/signatures. That could end up being a lot of work for the staff who don't even get paid to do any of this, and it will supposedly get more and more difficult to tell if something is AI generated as AI improves (
barf). But idk, maybe I am overthinking it, maybe it wouldn't be that difficult to deal with.. I personally don't have high expectations for such a ban, as nice as that would be.
I love the collectibles, they are very cute and oddly addictive at times. I think the market is kinda insane, but I have come to accept that the majority of my collectibles will come from the events alone. And to be fair, if you are patient enough and have the time to participate in events, you can accumulate a decent collection. The thing that gets me is FOMO; I often feel the need to participate in almost every single event because if I don't participate but there are some collectibles that I want, then I'm pretty much outta luck because I usually have less than 500 TBT, and lately there are always a few collectibles from an event that only sold a couple dozen or so and become impossible to find (Old Gameboy and Edgourd from the last Halloween event, for example). It could be years until those collectibles come around again. Even if I do fully participate, I usually end up a few collectibles short from what I wanted.. I think the event collectible prices could stand to be lowered.
Temporarily unique event collectibles are just frustrating. I understand collectibles like the candy canes being unique, but why Ice Cream Kitty Cone and the zodiac figurines?
I wish the normal shop was utilized more. Like why not add a few out-of-season event collectibles there, to be bought with TBT (hopefully under 1k and unlimited stock... I really hate limited stock). Rotate the selection every once in a while, maybe they could be available to buy in between events. I think the exotic fruit and perfect fruit collectibles would make for a really good permanent addition to the normal shop.
I think the events are so much fun. They make holidays like Halloween and Christmas more exciting and memorable for me since I'm far away from a lot of my family, and, well, those holidays just aren't the same here in Australia. Making animal crossing art over the years has really had a positive effect on me mentally and artistically; I wouldn't have made so much AC art if it weren't for this site.
I do think the "effort" debacle was a bit odd.. I think the rules in regards to art events could use some further revision and reconsideration. I don't know I agree about the proposed beginner, intermediate, and advanced categories; I think that could result in more drama, because you may think of yourself as a beginner but actually be intermediate or advanced, or vice versa. Or someone who is advanced could deliberately place themselves in the beginner category in order to give themselves better odds at winning.. it wouldn't be hard for an advanced artist to make art look high-end beginner.
Or suppose there are skill categories AND different art categories (2D, 3D, Food) -- what if someone is advanced in 2D art but has never worked in 3D before? Would they qualify for beginner 3D? Where would one draw the line? What if someone new to baking enters the beginner Food category, completely knocks it out of the park with their entry, and people accuse them of lying about being a beginner baker? Flukes can happen..
Some events can get a little
too competitive, like the last Camp Bell Tree.... let's just say I hope the next one really discourages poor sportsmanship
As far as the Animal Crossing side goes, I think it's perfect for those who want to buy in-game items and villagers! That was my whole reason for coming to this website in the first place. I love that you can buy those things with forum currency. It is so fast and efficient. The feedback system is very reassuring. And a lot of people are very generous and give items/villagers away for free. That's super cool
I wish the gyroid emotes would come back.
Overall, I think this is a really cool little corner of the internet. I am really glad I found it. Hopefully it can be improved!