which Animal Crossing game has been your favorite?.

it’s a tie between new leaf and new horizons; nl was my absolute favourite for years and is what really made me love the series. i have so many fond memories of playing + the people i met whilst doing so and it also has loads of features and furniture that i love! but on the other hand, i adore nh, too; the quality’s gorgeous and i love the fact that we can place furniture outside, now. sure, there’s still quite a bit of npcs + furniture options missing and i’m still not too fond of repetitive tool breakage but other than those, nh is definitely one of my favourite games of all time c’:
 
Last edited:
I've only ever played New Leaf, Happy Home Designer, and New Horizons. I tried to get in to Pocket Camp but I was very put off by the micro-transactions. It's just not right for an AC game IMO.

Anyway, NL was great, but I think I prefer NH. NH is just gorgeous. I can't wait to see where it will be in 2-3 years time. HHD was alright but got stale pretty fast. Thinking about trying Wild World someday
 
My rankings probably:
Acnl > acnh > acgc > acww > accf

Once all the acnh updates are released, maybe it'll surpass acnl for me but so far acnl is still my fav! I just love all the items and things to do in that game. I love the gamecube one too for just the dialogue haha, and the cute events like sports day! That game just has so much character, animal crossings def gone in a diff direction since then lol
 
I thiiiink new leaf is the only AC game I haven't played (?), since my chunky old DS was long gone by the time it came out. I have a lot of fondness for AC on the gamecube just because I was a tween at the time and there's a lot of nostalgia there, but the one I've logged the most hours in is definitely wild world. WW has my favourite hourly music too, and was the first time I found myself getting actually attached to specific villagers and NPCs (brewster please come back ;__; ). honestly though, despite its many shortcomings, I really have been enjoying NH (although I'm curious about NL since everyone here seems to rate it so highly)! so I think overall...hmmm...

ACNH = ACWW > ACGC > ACCF

but for hourly music it's like

ACWW >>>>>>>> ACGC > ACCF > ACNH
 
It's a really tough choice!

Being able to create patterns with transparency, the ability to decorate outside + decorate in half-grid increments, the ability to pick up trees and put them somewhere else, terraforming, island hopping for new villagers + villagers not moving without asking, etc... all of those things make New Horizons really great for those of us who like to have so much creative control over our islands.

New Leaf is just great in general, and I have so many great memories playing it with my best friend. I also loved going to the island at night to catch beetles with that PREMIUM island set up lol, and there was so much great furniture that I love and miss, like so many great food items, versatile furniture sets such as Alpine, Sloppy, and Rococo. Interactions with villagers were more fun too, even if all the delivery requests / house invites / etc. could get a bit overwhelming sometimes.

I didn't care for City Folk honestly so even though I played it, I don't have much to say.

I haven't played Wild World (weirdly) so I can't comment on that, but I've heard it was great. Unfortunately, with all that we can do in NH, I think I would get bored with it so it's a shame I didn't try it earlier.


Gamecube / Population Growing... where to even begin. I love this game. Your day would consist of delivering a watch to a villager, getting called ugly by another villager while you're just trying to vibe, having a villager let you know they painted your roof without permission, and then having them proceed to call you ungrateful when you get upset. Maybe make a mistake and reset and then have Resetti yell at you for 5 minutes before making you type out "I'm a loser." Scrubbing Gracie's car and getting an ugly shirt in return for your hard work, and yet waiting in anticipation for her next visit. Premium gameplay, 10/10, I wouldn't have changed a thing. I played this game for hours and hours as a child, sometimes I wonder what I even did all day in that game, but I loved it and it was a very important part of my childhood tbh!

So all in all, it's very hard to choose since they're all great (except City Folk in my own personal opinion), and each one has something unique about it that I love. Just so I have an answer, I will say New Leaf because of the great memories with my best friend and also for all the super fun times I had playing it alone too, but I'm not even really sure which one is actually my favourite!
 
Gamecube / Population Growing... where to even begin. I love this game. Your day would consist of delivering a watch to a villager, getting called ugly by another villager while you're just trying to vibe, having a villager let you know they painted your roof without permission, and then having them proceed to call you ungrateful when you get upset.

oh my god, the memories this brought back
don't forget those wild gift chains where you'd pass along like 5 different items to 5 different villagers who would wander off constantly and make you hunt them down until you were sure they'd just straight-up vanished...
I still remember olivia moving into my very first ACGC town and immediately telling me my clothes were hideous and she was embarrassed for me lol
 
New Horizons has been my favorite so far. It's been the AC game I've poured the most hours into and the only AC game I've played daily for 6 months (and counting). I've really enjoyed everything we've been able to do up to this point and being able to play it with my friends, and I'm definitely looking forward to the updates that lie ahead.

As a side note, my ranking of all games would be:
NH > WW > NL > AC >>> CF
 
hard to say. i played WW and NL before this, and there are elements of both i'd want in NH. but since i've played NH i've tried to pick both games back up and can't get into it bc they're missing a lot of the new features i love in NH. so for now i'd say NH, but i love NL just as much.
 
Based on the two AC games I’ve played—ACNL and ACNH. ACNL will always get a thumbs up for favorite in the franchise.
 
I haven’t decided between new leaf and new horizon. I like the graphics and the ability for design outside in new horizon, however, for my customization aesthetics, new leaf was more enjoyable. There were more items to choose from. Also, new leaf had gyroids, which are my favorite. And dead trees.
 
I do have a copy of New Leaf somewhere. I do remember things like having to be careful where you walk because the grass would otherwise turn into mud paths, little control over villagers arriving/leaving, and little control over your town in general (no terraforming and no determining where villagers would live or moving their homes).

I like that all these things are fixed in New Horizons. I've definitely played New Horizons for longer than I ever played New Leaf, and I think it's because I don't have to worry about stuff like I just described above.

I believe people when they say New Leaf was better because it offered more dialogs or items than New Horizons, but I haven't played enough New Leaf (and what little I played was so long ago) that I have enough memory of either of those to miss them. So for me, New Horizons is definitely the best.
 
I’d have to say that NH has been my favorite game out of the series because of its customizability. I hear “bring back all the items from NL” and while I’d love these items to come back eventually honestly I don’t remember half of them (and a good chunk of the stuff I do remember I wouldn’t think of using because it clashes with my aesthetic). Maybe it’s just that I like the themes that are available (I’m a sucker for foresty stuff) and I don’t blame those who’s ideas would benefit from those items for wanting them back.
 
Every game has something that I love more than another game, but I would say NH is my favorite. There are elements of every other game I wish NH had, but I could say that about every game they have done compared to the others.
One thing I really wish we had is the ability to have multiple islands without having to have a different switch for each of them. There are little things I wish were in this game, but that is the biggest issue I have right now, because every game I have gotten bored eventually and creating a new town is what kept me going on all of them.
I have never just owned one copy of an AC game, this is a first for me...I am kind of salty about it lol
 
NH is my favorite. I played WW and CF when I was a kid, but I never knew what I was doing. I didn’t play daily and never completed anything in those games. I also really don’t like when villagers would move out randomly.
 
I'd currently have to say New Leaf. It's the happy balance between Animal Crossing for the GameCube and New Horizons for me. New Leaf's dialogue isn't as good as Animal Crossing for the GameCube, but it's better than the dialogue in New Horizons. New Leaf's furniture and clothing offerings are superior to the GameCube game's and the lack of a lot of this stuff can make New Horizons feel a bit barren in comparison. Being the mayor and having the ability to construct Public Works Projects is fun. There's a good selection of shops available on Main Street, plus it's enjoyable to work at The Roost Café and be able to carry around and drink a to-go coffee. Then of course there's Tortimer's Island which my best friend and I got a lot of use out of and which we very much hope might return in New Horizons. New Leaf is overall just a really strong game and none of the others can really compete, in my opinion.

Second place would probably go to New Horizons because, while it's missing a lot of the stuff we had come to expect from Animal Crossing games, the experience it offers is still fun in its own way. Hopefully its best days are still ahead of it and some of the beloved aspects that people have been requesting might make their return through updates over the next couple years.

Third place goes to Animal Crossing for the GameCube. It's a wonderful game with a lot of great, unique aspects that make it stand out, but certain things like storage feel a bit too archaic now.

Never played Wild World and have no interest in doing so at this point, and really disliked City Folk. Never played Happy Home Designer but wouldn't be opposed to maybe trying it someday. Also never played Pocket Camp and have no interest, despite the cool items. Amiibo Festival could have been a cute, fun board game if it wasn't as much of a money grab as it ended up being.
 
ACNL > AC:WW > AC:GCN = ACNH & I haven't played City Folk.
Man ACNL was such a glow up from WW... I kind of can't believe we hopped from WW to ACNL lol

ACNL and ACNH feel like games in the same series, but ACNH feels only loosely related to WW or AC:GCN in my opinion. ACNL is the bridge, the link, between the old style of AC & the new style and I'm very afraid that we'll never get a game like it again. It had the perfect balance in my opinion of daily interaction with villagers/shopkeepers & focus on decorating. Plus it added so many features that are slowly returning or are absent completely from both older titles AND new horizons. For lack of a better word, the game is a complete experience that you can only get from Animal Crossing.
 
My favorite is the original AC for the GameCube. It was my introduction to the series and it just has this feeling that the newer games cannot replicate. I'm not really much of a landscaper or decorator. The joy of the game for me comes from interacting with my villagers and the NPCs. Winning over the villagers felt so rewarding back then because they weren't all nice right from the start.

I have enjoyed my time with New Leaf and I'm still playing it to finish up my second town, but after a while it began to feel lacking to me because of the dialogue issues. I miss Blathers' speeches and the feeling of truly earning a villager's friendship.

I was hoping New Horizons would bring some of that back, but the series seems to be going in the opposite direction. And I just couldn't care less about terraforming, farming, or putting furniture outside. So I'll probably go back to GameCube eventually for the nostalgia or maybe try out Wild World since I've heard so many good things about it.
 
ACNL is my current favorite, but once ACNH has all the old items from New Leaf added and more new features, then it’ll likely replace ACNL in my heart. I’ve been patiently waiting for all the cute RV-specific furniture (especially the Fairy Bottle TuT).
 
Back
Top