• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Newbie Mini Mafia III: Captain Flint's Gold (Game Over/Town Wins)

8floor said:
it might not have meant much, yeah, but it was not the equivalent of checking in. by asking what we would be doing for the game, sid was telling us to get to playing rather than posting useless junk. as for my activity in portal, that is because that game started at night and no one wants to drag attention to themselves yet.

alright. defense.

if i were scum, why would i put myself into the spotlight so drastically, knowing that it would make me immediately look suspicious. as scum, i would be better off just sitting to the wayside and waiting, as i have done in other games, because if i just "checked in" i would be under less suspicion than i am now. if i put myself in the spotlight, i would be hurting my whole scum team if i were lynched.

also, i do not understand how it would be scummy to say "x player is probably town" as opposed to saying "y player is probably scum"
in a game with no pm, i think we need to put our suspicions on the table, be it whether we think people are town or scum. we need to be more open, yet less open at the same time.

(in other news, since you guys seem to read so hard into other games, i am trying to change my playstyle so i do not dig myself into the hole of looking perpetually scummy and getting lynched day 1 all the time :p )

- - - Post Merge - - -

berrypop
puppy
mahoushoujo27
mrkisstoufur
in-a-pickle
honeyprince
littlebeary

listed people have not posted anything of substance so far.
come on down, say something other than "checking in"

- - - Post Merge - - -

also i will be gone until 8pm pst (estimate)
Click to expand...

Yikes, I swear no one lives on the West Coast xD The thead is full of posts when I wake up, but totally dead when I'm active on the forum.

AnYwAy....I'm reviewing all the posts now.
 
8floor said:
it might not have meant much, yeah, but it was not the equivalent of checking in. by asking what we would be doing for the game, sid was telling us to get to playing rather than posting useless junk. as for my activity in portal, that is because that game started at night and no one wants to drag attention to themselves yet.

alright. defense.

if i were scum, why would i put myself into the spotlight so drastically, knowing that it would make me immediately look suspicious. as scum, i would be better off just sitting to the wayside and waiting, as i have done in other games, because if i just "checked in" i would be under less suspicion than i am now. if i put myself in the spotlight, i would be hurting my whole scum team if i were lynched.

also, i do not understand how it would be scummy to say "x player is probably town" as opposed to saying "y player is probably scum"
in a game with no pm, i think we need to put our suspicions on the table, be it whether we think people are town or scum. we need to be more open, yet less open at the same time.

(in other news, since you guys seem to read so hard into other games, i am trying to change my playstyle so i do not dig myself into the hole of looking perpetually scummy and getting lynched day 1 all the time :p )

- - - Post Merge - - -

berrypop
puppy
mahoushoujo27
mrkisstoufur
in-a-pickle
honeyprince
littlebeary

listed people have not posted anything of substance so far.
come on down, say something other than "checking in"

- - - Post Merge - - -

also i will be gone until 8pm pst (estimate)
Click to expand...
Did I miss something? I didn't see PrayingMantis or anyone else mention the Portal game.

As for your playstyle, I've obviously never played with you before but I've watched games you were in and I remember you saying that you didn't quite like the way those games were played, so it doesn't surprise me that you'd try to be a bit more "aggressive", for lack of a better word, in this game.
 
gnoixaim said:
Okay, how are you "absolutely" sure Sid is town? I just find it fishy that you're so sure of yourself. And then you also state the whole "reverse psychology" thing, that you or Sid could be using.

---



Awe :'D Thank you for the compliment, LOL. (I'm a girl btw + I'm a total noob at this game, this is only my 3rd one!)

I do suggest the detective to inspect (or at least keep an eye out) for players that are likely to fly under the radar, but it's first day and I'm sure most players will be contributing to avoid suspicion. So, you really just have to go with the flow for now until something sparks your eye :) (c'mon it's day 1, actions can't even be used yet. Lol)

---


I remember last time Chibi.Hoshi was "inactive" due to their timezone and I don't think we should vote for them just for that same reason again.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think we should go with a different tactic (from those who have played the last game) instead of lynching a seemingly inactive player.
 
8floor said:
it might not have meant much, yeah, but it was not the equivalent of checking in. by asking what we would be doing for the game, sid was telling us to get to playing rather than posting useless junk. as for my activity in portal, that is because that game started at night and no one wants to drag attention to themselves yet.

alright. defense.

if i were scum, why would i put myself into the spotlight so drastically, knowing that it would make me immediately look suspicious. as scum, i would be better off just sitting to the wayside and waiting, as i have done in other games, because if i just "checked in" i would be under less suspicion than i am now. if i put myself in the spotlight, i would be hurting my whole scum team if i were lynched.

also, i do not understand how it would be scummy to say "x player is probably town" as opposed to saying "y player is probably scum"
in a game with no pm, i think we need to put our suspicions on the table, be it whether we think people are town or scum. we need to be more open, yet less open at the same time.

(in other news, since you guys seem to read so hard into other games, i am trying to change my playstyle so i do not dig myself into the hole of looking perpetually scummy and getting lynched day 1 all the time :p )

- - - Post Merge - - -

berrypop
puppy
mahoushoujo27
mrkisstoufur
in-a-pickle
honeyprince
littlebeary

listed people have not posted anything of substance so far.
come on down, say something other than "checking in"

- - - Post Merge - - -

also i will be gone until 8pm pst (estimate)
Click to expand...
i dont really know what to post, no one seems suspicious
 
Other than someone bringing up 8floor for posting differently compared to their previous games, I have absolutely zero substantial evidence. I would say we go for a no lynch, but that seems like a bad idea to be honest. From what I can gather thus far, Mahou hasn't posted since the Day post last night and they've been active in the IRC a few times this has all been going down. If anything, lynching an inactive would be our best option considering they're just cripple town in the long run anyways.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*they'll
 
Ok I guess we lynch the most inactive or least helpful player since no lynch is not an option.
 
aight ive been at band camp so
lets just agree that a no lynch is out of the question
right now the best bet seems to be 8floor because that one-liner from sid really doesnt say anything about alignment and it seems odd that you would think it does.
8floor said:
we need to be more open, yet less open at the same time.
Click to expand...
um what does this even mean
shouldnt you explain your reasoning better than that if youre going to defend yourself?

8floor said:
since you guys seem to read so hard into other games, i am trying to change my playstyle
Click to expand...
okay then why did you even bother to say this:
8floor said:
i would be better off just sitting to the wayside and waiting, as i have done in other games
Click to expand...
why would you try so hard to change your playstyle for that reasoning anyway? that would make it harder for town to figure out if youre scum or not (which isnt good)??

if 8floor manages to avoid a lynch the det might want to do some inspecting here

(im trying guys okay)

- - - Post Merge - - -

i got ninja'd so bad oops
 
8floor you say you are going to change your play style so you don't look scummy and get lynched day 1 like in former games yet in XCom you actually died night two ( not a lynching) and in Mean Girls you didn't die at all. Where are all these day 1 lynchings? Could you please come back with a defense that makes sense. Thank you.
 
I'm trying to get mahou to post, I've pm'd her in irc but idk if she's just ignoring it or if she's afk
And going back to waffles post I would like to hear like their opinions as to what's going on right now
 
Capella said:
I'm trying to get mahou to post, I've pm'd her in irc but idk if she's just ignoring it or if she's afk
And going back to waffles post I would like to hear like their opinions as to what's going on right now
Click to expand...

I know I'm just a coach but this IS a no PM game.
 
Last edited:
oath2order said:
I know I'm just a coach but this IS a no PM game.
Click to expand...

oath2order you edited. You're setting a bad example. Modkilled.

More seriously: do not contact people outside of the thread at all about the game. I received word that some of you have been talking about the game, and even though it wasn't serious (or directly about what's happening) it still isn't allowed. It's too easy to get carried away.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
812
N e s s
N e s s
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
95K
unravel
unravel
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
48K
Jacob4
Jacob4
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Voting Thread
5 6 7
Replies
122
Views
4K
Damniel
Damniel
Back
Top