The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Dwayne Johnson]

View attachment 253126

My order is

1. Zucker
2. Marshal
3. Marina
4. Maple
5. Julian
6. Punchy
7. Octavian
8. Cookie
9. Renneigh
10. Bob

10. julian
9. reneigh
8. marina
7. marshal
6. cookie
5. maple
4. bob
3. zucker
2. octavian
1. punchy

 

[Xara]

10. julian
9. flora
8. reneigh
7. lucky
6. kid cat
5. vivian
4. lily
3. zucker
2. static
1. coco

Post automatically merged: May 4, 2020

View attachment 253075
reposting my list

10. eugene
9. kyle
8. camofrog
7. cyd
6. scoot
5. tangy
4. bob
3. punchy
2. lolly
1. audie

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

revive bump

 

[TearsFromEatingFlan]

View attachment 253093

10/10 dreamies

1. Sherb
2. Raymond
3. Julian
4. Roald
5. Judy
6. Cyd
7. Bob
8. Paula??
9. Chrissy
10. Gayle

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

View attachment 252975
rank my current villagers!!

10. Agnes
9. Bianca
8. Raymond
7. Whitney
6. Melba
5. Roald
4. Wolfgang
3. Alfonso
2. Marina
1. Audie

 

[Xara]

My dreamies list already have half of them!

1. Merengue
2. Coco
3. Pashima
4. Flora
5. Tank
6. Anabelle
7. Antonio
8. Lily
9. Lolly
10. Ozzie

10. tank
9. coco
8. flora
7. ozzie
6. antonio
5. anabelle
4. merengue
3. lily
2. pashmina
1. lolly

 

[skylucario]

RANK MY VILLAGERS:
agnes, sheldon, punchy, daisy, dotty, marshal, butch, baabara, molly, antonio

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

View attachment 252975
rank my current villagers!!

1. Agnes
2. Raymond
3. Melba
4. Wolfgang
5. Alfonso
6. Audie
7. Roald
8. Whitney
9. Marina
10. Bianca

 

[Xara]

RANK MY VILLAGERS:
agnes, sheldon, punchy, daisy, dotty, marshal, butch, baabara, molly, antonio

10. baabara
9. sheldon
8. antonio
7. butch
6. dotty
5. punchy
4. molly
3. agnes
2. marshal
1. daisy

 

[PinkyPoo]

I like most of my villagers (Except Lyman, please move). My personal rankings for them are:
10. Lyman (He's not even in good shape, always eats donuts and constantly flexes on my villager. He pretends he's going to move but just hands me a crumby ugly shirt instead).
9. Paula (I'm not a big fan of her design but she's very nice).
8. Louie (He at least works out! Unlike Lyman who just pretends to.)
7. Rudy (While he is yet another jock, he's also a cat and that's pretty cool).
6. Astrid (Literally just moved in today, but I like how she looks like a juggalo).
5. Chops (He's just a snooty pig and I love it).
4. Mathilda (She keeps building rare DIY's and is very sweet).
3. Kyle (He's a cool wolf, need I say more?)
2. Cube (He's so cute!)
1. Octavian (The OG. GRUMPY OCTOPUS BOI).

Sorry if there are Lyman fans who read that, I'm sure on other islands, he's a nice guy, but I'm telling you, he just flashes that donut at me to trigger me.

 

[Xara]

I'd like to try this! I'll also rank other's villagers once I take a look through the thread <3

My Villagers and personal list for them
1. Goldie
2. Kyle
3. Fang
4. Audie
5. Lucky
6. Freya
7. Biskit
8. Cherry
9. Daisy
10. Chief

10. kyle
9. biskit
8. chief
7. lucky
6. cherry
5. fang
4. freya
3. goldie
2. daisy
1. audie

 

[axaniao]

My current villagers I love them all SM
My personal ranking:
1. O'Hare (duh)
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Tom
5. Static
6. Snake
7. Lolly
8. Genji
9. Sherb
10. Punchy

I love them all tho
What do you guys think?

 

[kiriod]

my current villagers are genji, raymond, sherb, poppy, coco, dobie, pekoe, bree, and zucker. i'm curious how people rank them, since i consider them all to be good villagers!

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

View attachment 253831
My current villagers I love them all SM
My personal ranking:
1. O'Hare (duh)
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Tom
5. Static
6. Snake
7. Lolly
8. Genji
9. Sherb
10. Punchy

I love them all tho
What do you guys think?

hmm...
1. genji
2. raymond
3. lolly
4. punchy
5. marshal
6. o'hare
7. static
8. snake
9. tom
10. sherb

 

[peachycrossing9]

View attachment 253831
My current villagers I love them all SM
My personal ranking:
1. O'Hare (duh)
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Tom
5. Static
6. Snake
7. Lolly
8. Genji
9. Sherb
10. Punchy

I love them all tho
What do you guys think?

Oof, you have adorable villagers!

1. Punchy
2. Lolly
3. Sherb
4. Marhsal
5. Raymond
6. O'Hare
7. Tom
8. Static
9. Genji
10. Snake

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

View attachment 252975
rank my current villagers!!

Omg your villagers are precious.

1. Alfonso (Hes my baby :3)
2. Wolfgang
3. Melba
4. Bianca
5. Audie
6. Whitney
7. Marina
8. Raymond
9. Roald
10. Agnes

Post automatically merged: May 6, 2020

I'd like to try this! I'll also rank other's villagers once I take a look through the thread <3

My Villagers and personal list for them
1. Goldie
2. Kyle
3. Fang
4. Audie
5. Lucky
6. Freya
7. Biskit
8. Cherry
9. Daisy
10. Chief

For me it goes:

1. Goldie
2. Fang
3. Audie
4. Daisy
5. Chief
6. Freya
7. Kyle
8. Cherry
9. Lucky
10. Biskit

 

[MrPicard]

I've put the ranking of mine into my signature (favorite on the left, least favorite on the right). I'm trying to get rid of Olaf and Sprocket, I don't really care for them. But all the others I've really come to appreciate by now.

 

[Xara]

my current villagers are genji, raymond, sherb, poppy, coco, dobie, pekoe, bree, and zucker. i'm curious how people rank them, since i consider them all to be good villagers!

9. genji
8. raymond
7. coco
6. bree
5. pekoe
4. sherb
3. poppy
2. dobie
1. zucker

 

[Khte]

View attachment 253831
My current villagers I love them all SM
My personal ranking:
1. O'Hare (duh)
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Tom
5. Static
6. Snake
7. Lolly
8. Genji
9. Sherb
10. Punchy

I love them all tho
What do you guys think?

1. GENJI
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Sherb
5. Punchy
6. Tom
7. Lolly
8. O'Hare
9. Static
10. Snake

 

[Xara]

View attachment 253831
My current villagers I love them all SM
My personal ranking:
1. O'Hare (duh)
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Tom
5. Static
6. Snake
7. Lolly
8. Genji
9. Sherb
10. Punchy

I love them all tho
What do you guys think?

10. snake
9. genji
8. o’hare
7. static
6. raymond
5. punchy
4. tom
3. sherb
2. marshal
1. lolly

 

[leenaby]

So far my personal ranking is (or currently since most aren't my permanent residents except for maybe like 4 or 5 people on this list):

10. Sheldon
9. Cherry
8. Knox
7. Rosie
6. Diana
5. Julian
4. Dobie
3. Francine
2. Sherb (he's so sweet!)
1. Genji (he writes me letters and I love talking to him and we're BFFs I think?)

 

[Xara]

So far my personal ranking is (or currently since most aren't my permanent residents except for maybe like 4 or 5 people on this list):

10. Sheldon
9. Cherry
8. Knox
7. Rosie
6. Diana
5. Julian
4. Dobie
3. Francine
2. Sherb (he's so sweet!)
1. Genji (he writes me letters and I love talking to him and we're BFFs I think?)

10. knox
9. sheldon
8. genji
7. rosie
6. francine
5. cherry
4. sherb
3. julian
2. dobie
1. diana

 

[kiriod]

So far my personal ranking is (or currently since most aren't my permanent residents except for maybe like 4 or 5 people on this list):

10. Sheldon
9. Cherry
8. Knox
7. Rosie
6. Diana
5. Julian
4. Dobie
3. Francine
2. Sherb (he's so sweet!)
1. Genji (he writes me letters and I love talking to him and we're BFFs I think?)

1. genji!
2. diana
3. dobie
4. rosie
5. francine
6. julian
7. sherb
8. cherry
9. sheldon
10. knox (i'm biased cus he wouldn't leave my island for so long T_T)