Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[N e s s]

Maybe scum wanted it to look legit this time
I really wanted to lynch waffles but I'm like 2% conflicted now

The thing is, the PM was actually titled "Night Results". I can't tell if Bianca said that was the title of her PM or not but that kinda makes me inclined to think it might be real. That is unless scum somehow can manipulate the title of the PM, but the host is always the one who does that.

 

[Byngo]

ugh im torn on waffles now. assuming a scum whisperer has been sending the “reports” y would they send about their teammate who was heavily sus’d

- - - Post Merge - - -

The thing is, the PM was actually titled "Night Results". I can't tell if Bianca said that was the title of her PM or not but that kinda makes me inclined to think it might be real. That is unless scum somehow can manipulate the title of the PM, but the host is always the one who does that.

the message i got from you was titled night results

 

[N e s s]

ugh im torn on waffles now. assuming a scum whisperer has been sending the “reports” y would they send about their teammate who was heavily sus’d

If it's truly randomly sent to people, I find it incredibly convenient how it was sent to me, the president, right after I had just created a long post about Waffles.

 

[Jacob]

Something I just thought about, the scum team's kills aren't seeming very checked in or elaborate, Day 1 they killed two of the best players in the game which I associated with a sort of tactic: maybe trying to frame the better players or set up an inspection on the godfather, but based on this recent night phase I think they're just taking out threats. If thats even the right wording for that. They killed Punchy, and the only reason for that that I can think of is because punchy is confirmed blue. But why even kill him? People have literally called him out for talking too much and being pretty distracting. Punchy didn't have any malicious powers against mafia or any powers at considerin dolby is dead, hes basically a townie. Why would they even kill him? Theres only 1 kill so either theres 2 mafia left or there is 3 and they targeted someone predictable enough to be saved by doc. Either way it makes sense that Waffles, and someone else who seems constantly not up to date with recent events would decide to kill the obvious choices.

on mobile didnt proofread

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Oh well I died that was coming lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

Trundleeee send me the obs chat link pwease

 

[cornimer]

If it's truly randomly sent to people, I find it incredibly convenient how it was sent to me, the president, right after I had just created a long post about Waffles.

I was just thinking that

And Bianca was sus of Locket (I think) before she got the Locket report

 

[Heyden]

I WAS SAVED ILY
also lmfao punchy what a meme i wasnt even confirmed town like him

- - - Post Merge - - -

i have some stuff i'll post later at school rn

 

[cornimer]

Idk, here is my thought process:

1. If these messages are both from an oracle, why is the formatting different? And also, what are the odds the oracle inspected scum twice in a row? This one SOUNDS legit especially since it was titled "Night Results" but why wasn't the first one like that?
2. Could the messages be from two different people? Three message-based roles? Unlikely
3. As Ness and I just said, the people these messages are being sent to is extremely convenient
4. I still have Other Reasons for believing this oracle investigation thing is likely a scam
5. Waffles is like suuuuper scummy but if she's not mafia, she's the best person to send a fake result on because everyone wanted to lynch her anyways. If she is mafia and scum is behind the messages, maybe they want to trick us into thinking the messages are reliable by bussing someone who was already going to get lynched?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I WAS SAVED ILY
also lmfao punchy what a meme i wasnt even confirmed town like him

- - - Post Merge - - -

i have some stuff i'll post later at school rn

YAY GOOD JOB DOC, but yikes there are still two kills out there

 

[Biancasbotique]

Btw...the title of the PM is "Night Results". @Bianca Was your message titled the same way, or is it literally "You got an anonymous message"? Because the anonymous message part of mine is actually inside the PM.

Yeah, its the same kind and format. except my mafia is in black.. Maybe mafia made sure to color the mafia this time.

 

[cornimer]

Yeah, its the same kind and format. except my mafia is in black.. Maybe mafia made sure to color the mafia this time.

Did the title specifically say "Night Results"??

 

[N e s s]

Okay honestly, if we have 2 mafia results from a supposed oracle, and we're going under the assumption that there is currently 3 mafia, I REALLY think it's a good idea for this "oracle" to come out and claim.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah, its the same kind and format. except my mafia is in black.. Maybe mafia made sure to color the mafia this time.

Does the title specifically state "Night Results"

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think Dolby agrees with me lol, he just liked my post

 

[cornimer]

Okay honestly, if we have 2 mafia results from a supposed oracle, and we're going under the assumption that there is currently 3 mafia, I REALLY think it's a good idea for this "oracle" to come out and claim.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Does the title specifically state "Night Results"

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think Dolby agrees with me lol, he just liked my post

Plot twist: Dolby is the oracle signaling to you from the grave

 

[glow]

i highly doubt an oracle exists

 

[Byngo]

that’s funny cuz dolby was the oracle in su2 mafia lol

 

[cornimer]

i highly doubt an oracle exists

Me Too

 

[N e s s]

i highly doubt an oracle exists

Exactly. If nobody comes out now after us supposedly having 2 guilty claims, then both messages should automatically be disregarded as false.

 

[glow]

Exactly. If nobody comes out now after us supposedly having 2 guilty claims, then both messages should automatically be disregarded as false.

i mean, honestly i tr'd locket 50% because of the message so maybe they tried to do the same thing w/ waff

 

[Byngo]

Okay honestly, if we have 2 mafia results from a supposed oracle, and we're going under the assumption that there is currently 3 mafia, I REALLY think it's a good idea for this "oracle" to come out and claim.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Does the title specifically state "Night Results"

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think Dolby agrees with me lol, he just liked my post

tbh think they would’ve already come forth d1 to confirm locket

if they don’t by eod2 we can 100% confirm an oracle doesn’t exist

 

[cornimer]

i mean, honestly i tr'd locket 50% because of the message so maybe they tried to do the same thing w/ waff

Ooh that's a good point. Make us think it's false so we don't lynch Waffles

 

[N e s s]

i mean, honestly i tr'd locket 50% because of the message so maybe they tried to do the same thing w/ waff

I still think Waffles isn't scum despite this don't get me wrong, I just want to see if an Oracle will step forward.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*is scum