Since I use 5 accounts in Animal Crossing it's an easy answer for me. I have a family plan so all 5 accounts are online capable for $45 a year. It would cost me $100 a year to upgrade to the expansion pack plan. A big oof especially since the N64/Genesis games have little interest to me. I'll just keep my existing plan and pay the $30ish* one time fee to have the AC DLC permanently for all my characters.
*I don't believe official pricing has been released for my country in terms of the DLC yet but I'm estimating $30ish based on the US price.
I was under the impression that you had to buy the DLC separately for each account you are planning to use it for. If this is true and you only have to buy the DLC once to have access to it across all account than buying the DLC separately just seems like a better family plan minus the two additional libraries of games. I was already on the fence about paying for an upgraded online plan as I already have Playstation Plus, Playstation Now, EA Play, and regular NSO and I have barely even scraped the surface of these subscriptions XD.
Talked to customer service about the DLC.
Here is more information: Can other users on the same island play Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise if I’m the only Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack member? For a Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack Individual Membership, only the account with the active membership can play it. An internet connection is required when launching the game.
With a Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack Family Membership, all accounts that are part of the Family Group can play Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise for the duration of their membership. An internet connection is required when launching the game.
If the DLC is purchased separately, other users on the same island can also play Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise if the console on which the contents are played is set as the Primary Console of the account that purchased it. On any other console, it can only be played on the account that purchased it.
The $50 is just $50 a year or $4.17 a month to be able to access the N64 and Sega games. Considering that the cheapest you can legally get the Zelda games is $10 each, and that's if you even own the system for it, the cost increase makes sense.I'm kinda confused about the membership plan - from what I understand, you can pay $50 to get access to AC DLC and N64 Genesis games, or pay $25 to own the AC DLC and still pay... $50 for access to the AC DLC and N64/Genesis games? Is there an option for people that don't necessarily care about AC but want to play N64 games? Or for people who want to buy and own the DLC, but also at some point upgrade their online membership to include N64 games? Is it $50 no matter what? Idk why that seems so weird to me but it does haha, especially since the DLC itself is only $25. It sounds like an okay deal to people who actually play AC, but a terrible deal for people who just want to play N64 games. The price increase for the online membership just seems so huge.
Initially I was just going to upgrade my online membership and pay $50 per year, but the truth is I don't play online much and I really don't play the NES/SNES games that are available that often, so I'm wondering if it would be smarter for me to buy the DLC to own and then upgrade my online membership later... but if I end up upgrading my membership anyway, it's like I'm double-dipping on the price of the DLCI don't know what I'm going to do honestly, neither options seems significantly better than the other.
I guess what I'm trying to say is, there should be some sort of middle tier online subscription for, say, $35ish for people who just want access to N64 games and don't want to pay for the animal crossing content. Then I would have no problem buying the DLC to own, and just increasing my subscription price a bit when I decide I want to play N64 games.
The DLC is a separate entity and I think Nintendo shot themselves in the foot including it with the NSO because people seem to be confused. The $30 increase is not because of the DLC. Folks said they'd pay more to access N64 games and now that option is here. But adding the DLC has people thinking that's the reason for the price rather than it being what it is: A promotional item.
This is true. They've also stated that if you lose the NSO account, you still get to keep the things like furniture or partitions that you earn in the DLC. You just don't get to keep going to the archipelago. Also, while Xbox Game Pass has modern games, I believe a 6 month subscription costs $60 and PS Now is $60.Because it's a promotional thing too, something I'd be concerned about is the availability of the DLC as part of that service long term. Even if you're the kind of person who just pays for NSO every single year because you want to play the retro games, if they take access to the DLC off of the service because they decide not to offer it as a feature anymore for whatever reason, then you also lose access to the DLC even if you're still paying for NSO expanded.
Nintendo doesn't have something comparable, but compare it to Microsoft and their Xbox Game Pass. Games come and go from availability from Xbox Game Pass. Since this site has a lot of Nintendo fans that don't necessarily pay attention to Microsoft, Xbox Game Pass is kind of comparable to the NES/SNES games that are on NSO, where you can only access them if you're paying for the online service. But with Xbox Game Pass, these are not retro games - they are current, modern games. Like I said earlier, each month new games come onto the service, but some games also leave. So you don't get access to a particular game forever, even if you keep up a subscription.
Nintendo has not promised either way that access to the HHP will be forever or not. But that is another advantage of the standalone DLC: they won't take it away from you.