The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Xara]

They're in my signature, but anyways I have:
Fang
Audie
Rudy
Kitty
Sherb
Nan
Lopez
Fauna
Stitches
Tammy

10. lopez
9. kitty
8. tammy
7.sherb
6. fang
5. stitches
4. nan
3. rudy
2. fauna
1. audie

 

[Skandranon]

10. Beau
9. Fauna
8 . Caroline
7. Skye
6. Phoebe
5. Reneigh
4. Julia
3. Chief
2. Audie
1. Whitney

 

[Islander]

Mine are:

Papi
Tad
Tucker
Goldie
Bianca
Kyle
Pancetti
Filbert
Agnes
Chevre

 

[Xara]

Mine are:

Papi
Tad
Tucker
Goldie
Bianca
Kyle
Pancetti
Filbert
Agnes
Chevre

10. tucker
9. pansetti
8. tad
7. filbert
6. bianca
5. chèvre
4. kyle
3. papi
2. agnes
1. goldie

 

[Catharina]

Mine are:

Papi
Tad
Tucker
Goldie
Bianca
Kyle
Pancetti
Filbert
Agnes
Chevre

10 Kyle (so sorry! ;( )
9 Tucker
8 Filbert
7 Tad
6 Bianca
5 Goldie
4 Papi
3 Pancetti
2 Agnes
1 Chevre

(For now) my villagers:
Coco
Erik
Boone
Pate
Poppy
Wilow
Tucker
Lolly
Apollo
Ruby

 

[Xara]

(For now) my villagers:
Coco
Erik
Boone
Pate
Poppy
Wilow
Tucker
Lolly
Apollo
Ruby

10. boone
9. tucker
8. apollo
7. coco
6. willow
5. ruby
4. erik
3. pate
2. poppy
1. lolly

 

[Aurita]

(For now) my villagers:
Coco
Erik
Boone
Pate
Poppy
Wilow
Tucker
Lolly
Apollo
Ruby

10 Boone
9 Tucker
8 Pate
7 Coco
6 Apollo
5 Lolly
4 Erik
3 Poppy
2 Willow
1 Ruby

Here are mine:
Goldie
Bones
Daisy
Flora
Judy
Raymond
Fang
Stitches
Bluebear
Genji

 

[WaileaNoRei]

They're in my signature, but anyways I have:
Fang
Audie
Rudy
Kitty
Sherb
Nan
Lopez
Fauna
Stitches
Tammy

1. Fauna
2. Kitty
4. Nan
5. Lopez
6. Tammy
7. Rudy
8. Stitches
9. Audie
10. Fang

I feel like Tammy is surprisingly low on this list, she’s great! Sorry to the wolfies, I’m just not a big fan of them as a group (though I am starting to like Skye, possibly from exposure to her from @xara and other’s pics. Not sure how to feel about that

I almost have all permanent villagers (or until I get their photos...), so rank my villagers! There's only one I'm planning to still boot, but I won't say who for now.

Agnes
Fang
Hopkins
Julia
Kyle
Lolly
Raymond
Rosie
Sprinkle
Tybalt

1. Agnes
2. Tybalt
3. Lolly
4. Rosie
5. Raymond
6. Hopkins
7. Sprinkle
8. Julia
9. Fang
10. Kyle

Love love love Agnes. And she and Tybalt and sprinkle all have the play hobby which sounds extra fun! What a varied and cute group!

 

[Dunquixote]

Mine are:

Papi
Tad
Tucker
Goldie
Bianca
Kyle
Pancetti
Filbert
Agnes
Chevre

1. Filbert
2. Agnes
3. Tad
4. Goldie
5. Bianca
6. Papi
7. Kyle
8. Tucker
9. Chevre
10. Pancetti

10 Kyle (so sorry! ;( )
9 Tucker
8 Filbert
7 Tad
6 Bianca
5 Goldie
4 Papi
3 Pancetti
2 Agnes
1 Chevre

(For now) my villagers:
Coco
Erik
Boone
Pate
Poppy
Wilow
Tucker
Lolly
Apollo
Ruby

1. Lolly
2. Poppy
3. Erik
4. Ruby
5. Erik
6. Coco
7. Willow
8. Tucker
9. Apollo
10. Boone

10 Boone
9 Tucker
8 Pate
7 Coco
6 Apollo
5 Lolly
4 Erik
3 Poppy
2 Willow
1 Ruby

Here are mine:
Goldie
Bones
Daisy
Flora
Judy
Raymond
Fang
Stitches
Bluebear
Genji

1. Raymond
2. Judy
3. Stitches
4. Genji
5. Bluebear
6. Bones
7. Goldie
8. Daisy
9. Flora
10. Fang

 

[Xara]

Here are mine:
Goldie
Bones
Daisy
Flora
Judy
Raymond
Fang
Stitches
Bluebear
Genji

10. genji
9. raymond
8. flora
7. bones
6. bluebear
5. judy
4. fang
3. daisy
2. stitches
1. goldie

 

[meela]

Here are mine!

• Judy
• Bones
• Maple
• Tipper
• Dom
• Marshal
• Fang
• Merry
• Fauna
• Reneigh

 

[Skunk]

My friends on the island rn : D..

- Wolfgang
- Genji
- Audie
- Derwin
- Graham
- Barold
- Melba
- Tipper
- Cherry
- Dom (Thinking about kicking out tho.)

 

[Xara]

My friends on the island rn : D..

- Wolfgang
- Genji
- Audie
- Derwin
- Graham
- Barold
- Melba
- Tipper
- Cherry
- Dom (Thinking about kicking out tho.)

10. dom
9. barold sorry birthday twin,,
8. graham
7. genji
6. wolfgang
5. derwin
4. tipper
3. melba
2. cherry
1. audie

 

[Dunquixote]

Here are mine!

• Judy
• Bones
• Maple
• Tipper
• Dom
• Marshal
• Fang
• Merry
• Fauna
• Reneigh

1. Marshal
2. Merry
3. Dom
4. Reneigh
5. Judy
6. Maple
7. Bones
9. Fauna
10. Tipper @Reneezombie

My friends on the island rn : D..

- Wolfgang
- Genji
- Audie
- Derwin
- Graham
- Barold
- Melba
- Tipper
- Cherry
- Dom (Thinking about kicking out tho.)

1. Dom
2. Genji
3. Audie
4. Graham
5. Melba
6. Derwin
7. Barold
8. Wolfgang
9. Tipper
10. Cherry

 

[_Rainy_]

1. Marshal
2. Merry
3. Dom
4. Reneigh
5. Judy
6. Maple
7. Bones
9. Fauna
10. Tipper @Reneezombie

Oh

1. Tipper
2.Marshal
3.Merry
4.Dom
5.Reneigh
6. Judy
7. Maple
8. Bones
9. Fauna
I fixed it for you

 

[meela]

Oh

1. Tipper
2.Marshal
3.Merry
4.Dom
5.Reneigh
6. Judy
7. Maple
8. Bones
9. Fauna
I fixed it for you

Tipper is my #1 dreamie villager. S+ tier name, S+ tier design S tier presonality!!
❤

 

[misstayleigh]

1. Fauna
2. Kitty
4. Nan
5. Lopez
6. Tammy
7. Rudy
8. Stitches
9. Audie
10. Fang

I feel like Tammy is surprisingly low on this list, she’s great! Sorry to the wolfies, I’m just not a big fan of them as a group (though I am starting to like Skye, possibly from exposure to her from @xara and other’s pics. Not sure how to feel about that



1. Agnes
2. Tybalt
3. Lolly
4. Rosie
5. Raymond
6. Hopkins
7. Sprinkle
8. Julia
9. Fang
10. Kyle

Love love love Agnes. And she and Tybalt and sprinkle all have the play hobby which sounds extra fun! What a varied and cute group!

finally! some love for Tybalt haha ;-) it’s so fun seeing others rank ‘em, but it makes me sad Tybalt doesn’t get a lot of love! he reminds me of my big Maine Coon cat, too, so that’s also why I love him

if I had to rank my own, I’d probably say

1. Lolly
2. Tybalt
3. Rosie
4. Julia
5. Fang
6. Agnes
7. Kyle
8. Hopkins - I just got him but am not clicking. I think I’d rather have Cole, Wade, or Lucky for my lazy
9. Sprinkle - I’m going to let her go once she asks to move
??? Raymond - idk i never got the hype but he’s lowkey growing on me

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

Aw I wouldn't mind getting my villagers ranked! Just Muir Wood for now, since Inverness doesn't even have 10 villagers, let alone a "final" lineup.

• Deirdre
• Fauna
• Beau
• Shep
• Butch
• Genji
• Ruby
• Purrl
• Kiki
• Dom

1. Beau - my S/O's temporary lazy (he found Beau while island hopping and I asked him to adopt him). He is so sweet with his lazy eyes.
2. Fauna - very cute and natural looking
3. Butch
4. Kiki
5. Deirdre
6. Kiki
7. Genji
8. Shep
9. Purrl
10. Dom

My villagers:
- Kiki
- Felicity
- Punchy
- Ruby
- Henry
- Sherb
- Mint
- Cyd
- Goose
- Fuschia

1. Mint - totally underrated squirrel. Her colouring is so unique and pretty!
2. Punchy - one of my dream lazy villagers!
3. Felicity
4. Kiki
5. Fuschia - appreciate her design, minus the brightness, which I found even brighter in-person when she visited my S/O's campsite. XD
6. Ruby
7. Henry
8. Sherb
9. Cyd
10. Goose

My villagers:

- Ruby
- Wolfgang
- Stitches
- Genji
- Marshal
- Raymond
- Diana
- Ankha
- Coco
- Tasha

1. Diana - queen!
2. Stitches
3. Ankha
4. Tasha
5. Raymond
6. Wolfgang
7. Marshal
8. Coco
9. Genji
10. Ruby

I only have 5 so it's pretty easy haha. So far my ranking is:

1. Molly
2. Maddie
3. Rocket
4. Rodeo
5. Peck

1. Molly
2. Maddie
3. Peck
4. Rodeo
5. Rocket

I have:
Ankha
Lucky
Julian
Cookie
Purrl
Whitney
Marina
Dom
Wendy
Hazel

go for it!

1. Ankha
2. Julian
3. Cookie
4. Whitney
5. Lucky
6. Marina
7. Purrl
8. Wendy
9. Dom
10. Hazel

I just replaced Pierce with Beau, so my lineup is now:

-Erik
-Beau
-Deirdre
-Diana
-Bam
-Bruce
-Fauna
-Zell
-Audie
-Tex

1. Diana
2. Erik
3. Beau
4. Fauna
5. Deirdre
6. Zell
7. Bruce
8. Tex
9. Audie
10. Bam

They're in my signature, but anyways I have:
Fang
Audie
Rudy
Kitty
Sherb
Nan
Lopez
Fauna
Stitches
Tammy

1. Rudy
2. Stitches
3. Fauna
4. Fang
5. Kitty
6. Lopez
7. Sherb
8. Audie
9. Tammy
10. Nan

I almost have all permanent villagers (or until I get their photos...), so rank my villagers! There's only one I'm planning to still boot, but I won't say who for now.

Agnes
Fang
Hopkins
Julia
Kyle
Lolly
Raymond
Rosie
Sprinkle
Tybalt

1. Lolly
2. Rosie
3. Agnes
4. Raymond
5. Julia
6. Fang
7. Sprinkle
8. Kyle
9. Tybalt
10. Hopkins - is he an inflatable?

Mine are:

Papi
Tad
Tucker
Goldie
Bianca
Kyle
Pancetti
Filbert
Agnes
Chevre

1. Goldie
2. Agnes
3. Filbert
4. Bianca
5. Papi
6. Kyle
7. Tad
8. Tucker
9. Pancetti
10. Chevre

Here are mine!

• Judy
• Bones
• Maple
• Tipper
• Dom
• Marshal
• Fang
• Merry
• Fauna
• Reneigh

1. Bones
2. Judy
3. Maple
4. Fauna
5. Fang
6. Merry
7. Marshal
8. Reneigh
9. Dom
10. Tipper

 

[Roxxy]

Ok, my lovely islanders only one I am not 100% sure i am keeping

Audie
Julian
Whitney
Dobie
Reneigh
Bianca
Stiches
Ellie
Megan
Erik

 

[Seelie]

Ok, my lovely islanders only one I am not 100% sure i am keeping

Audie
Julian
Whitney
Dobie
Reneigh
Bianca
Stiches
Ellie
Megan
Erik

1. Erik -- he's just so cute, and if I hadn't already had him previously, he might have been my lazy on Muir Wood instead of Beau.
2. Dobie -- I just have the hugest soft spot for this old boy, even though I've never had him.
3. Audie -- I picked her up randomly on my old island and she really unexpectedly grew on me. She was constantly asking me questions and it felt like much more of an actual conversation than most of my other villagers that just chat for one or two lines.
4. Stitches
5. Reneigh -- not a huge horse fan but man her design with the piercings & the color fade is just really cool.
6. Whitney
7. Julian
8. Ellie -- the only reason she's not higher up is because I can't handle the sideways mouths, but she is otherwise quite cute.
9. Megan
10. Bianca -- love the idea of a snow leopard villager, but not a fan of the tiger villager models.