Pin the Tail on the Villager

[BetsySundrop]

Yay! Found the house list in order by Justin
https://animalcrossingworld.com/guides/new-horizons/villager-house-exterior-designs-complete-list/

That's the same list I was using. Cracked me up. So sneaky, haha

 

[TN4U]

The houses were in alphabetical order? No wonder I couldn't find it; Wilbur prevented me from finding it! I wonder who the heck got it right.

 

[MrBox]

Oh my god T__T (Sorry to my sibling LOL)
I thought it was D10 ...

 

[Aniko]

The alphabetical order was my first guess but then I confused Flurry house with Tipper and thought it was not that until I tried again.

 

[Suguri]

I was way off there, and I'm not surprised TBH.

 

[azurill]

Oh my god T__T (Sorry to my sibling LOL)
I thought it was D10 ...

Yea that was my guess too.

 

[Doo]

It confused me because Ace wasn’t there but as soon as I saw the AC world list I knew I was on the right track lol

 

[MiniPocketWorld]

So.. I picked G6 for Grahams birthday (June)
Plus Graham has 6 letters..

 

[Jhine7]

Well at least my guess of D7 is somewhat close

Very clever puzzle though!

 

[TN4U]

My guess was D3 as it was the last remaining house I could identify through the thick clouds. Looking at it now, it's clearly wrong!

 

[Aniko]

So.. I picked G6 for Grahams birthday (June)
Plus Graham has 6 letters..

Still close

 

[deana]

I put N 15 because through the clouds I thought it could *maybe* be the one.

I also spent a LOT of time looking for one house that would have it's chimney on thinking maybe that's what this puzzle was but of course I was wrong all around.

 

[Jeremy]

So.. I picked G6 for Grahams birthday (June)
Plus Graham has 6 letters..

Well that's certainly thinking outside the box! Maybe the wrong box, but at least you tried something!

 

[Giddy]

I think my guess was p12?
I would never of thought it was in alphabetical!! Thats such a cool way of looking at it!!

I did wanna say one thing, I dare not have said before we found out, but Graham's original house in New Leaf was completely different to the house he has now in NH. So, was hoping it wasn't a trick in that sense.

Good puzzle!!

 

[MrBox]

Gah! I thought this was a simple "look" to find the answer but.. I SEE..
These puzzles are relying on tricks now .... I'll put my thinking cap on now

 

[lieryl]

i would strongly like to be put back into the box, please

 

[Sharksheep]

I like these better than the mirrors. I'm not a nintendo fanatic so the mirrors were always the worse

 

[TN4U]

You know, there was one house that had its interior lights on; I forgot where it was but that had me think outside the box for a moment...

 

[Chere.]

That location was diabolical and I think everyone should be compensated for emotional damage

 

[Rio_]

I’m so happy I was able to figure out the alphabetical order thing!!!

I may have wasted hours carefully inspecting every house and messing with the brightness while zoomed in at 1000% trying to see what’s behind the clouds, but eventually I got there